Dear Physical Ranged DPS and..

[Miminming]

even if MCH dont have any utility its still on top in pyshical ranged RDPS, yes RDPS which mean including utility already, so buffing only MCah at this point is kinda wrong... if any BRD and DNC should be buffed to have more closer RDPS to MCH, ...if not more (because MCH can ignore other member to dish out their best rdps while DNC and BRD need a more strict teamplay for that)

saying damage buff utility blabla is pointless if you look at RDPS... the include that in the number already...

[Averax]

even if MCH dont have any utility its still on top in pyshical ranged RDPS, yes RDPS which mean including utility already, so buffing only MCah at this point is kinda wrong... if any BRD and DNC should be buffed to have more closer RDPS to MCH, ...if not more (because MCH can ignore other member to dish out their best rdps while DNC and BRD need a more strict teamplay for that)

saying damage buff utility blabla is pointless if you look at RDPS... the include that in the number already...

DNC and BRD don't have to do anything extra. Their utility is mostly baked into their damage rotations. Bards have to sing no matter what, it's part of their rotation. Dancers have to dance no matter what, standard step and technical step are their hardest hitting abilities.

You suggest making MCH effectively a straight up loss to bring along, but the reason it needs to do more damage is because that's all it brings (and a damage reduction skill). It needs to bring enough of its own damage to make it appealing enough to take up a slot reserved for a dancer or bard.

DNC and BRD are competitive because they raise everybody else's damage instead of doing a bunch themselves. The extra damage they make people do is counted towards their personal damage.

[ReiMakoto]

DNC and BRD don't have to do anything extra. Their utility is mostly baked into their damage rotations. Bards have to sing no matter what, it's part of their rotation. Dancers have to dance no matter what, standard step and technical step are their hardest hitting abilities.

You suggest making MCH effectively a straight up loss to bring along, but the reason it needs to do more damage is because that's all it brings (and a damage reduction skill). It needs to bring enough of its own damage to make it appealing enough to take up a slot reserved for a dancer or bard.

DNC and BRD are competitive because they raise everybody else's damage instead of doing a bunch themselves. The extra damage they make people do is counted towards their personal damage.

Mch already deals more damage when accounting for the dancer and bard buffs going to their own damage though, thats what rdps means

[Averax]

Mch already deals more damage when accounting for the dancer and bard buffs going to their own damage though, thats what rdps means

The guy is implying that they need to do less personal damage than dancer and bard because those two have more responsibility.

[Akiudo]

DNC and BRD don't have to do anything extra. Their utility is mostly baked into their damage rotations. Bards have to sing no matter what, it's part of their rotation. Dancers have to dance no matter what, standard step and technical step are their hardest hitting abilities.

You suggest making MCH effectively a straight up loss to bring along, but the reason it needs to do more damage is because that's all it brings (and a damage reduction skill). It needs to bring enough of its own damage to make it appealing enough to take up a slot reserved for a dancer or bard.

DNC and BRD are competitive because they raise everybody else's damage instead of doing a bunch themselves. The extra damage they make people do is counted towards their personal damage.

The guy is implying that they need to do less personal damage than dancer and bard because those two have more responsibility.

the post you originally quoted literally stated "

even if MCH dont have any utility its still on top in pyshical ranged RDPS, yes RDPS ....BRD and DNC should be buffed to have more closer RDPS to MCH, ...if not more (because MCH can ignore other member to dish out their best rdps while DNC and BRD need a more strict teamplay for that)

saying damage buff utility blabla is pointless if you look at RDPS... the include that in the number already...

while he did say "if not more because...." that is something one could argue, though its mostly a different discussion that is not specific to physical ranged but to every class and the general value of damage buffs, in no way however did his post say "dnc and brd should deal more personal dps than mch or that this had anything to do with extra responsibilitys on their part.