Dark Knight moving forward: Job change ideas for 6.0

[DRKoftheAzure]

You're pulling some pretty wild numbers out of nowhere.

Just casually dropping a 900 potency boost per minute on C&S, giving it a 900 potency cure for no reason, giving it charges so I'm assuming you'd be firing it off twice per minute to boot? Oh and let's give DRK a +20% damage boost to everything it does all the time.

20 second invulnerability? LOL. On top of it then losing the healing requirement?

Living Dead is so bad that even if Carve and Spit got the base potency and base MP recovery and had 1200 cure potency equivalent slapped on to, it wouldn't do much to fix it. Though it would give DRK a better flavor of tank though.

You don't like current DRK, I get it.

HUGE understatement right there.

The things you're suggesting "should" have been done however make absolutely no sense and it looks like to me that you're just slinging whatever mud you can find at DRK and then bringing in a wheelbarrow just so you can bring some more mud that isn't even there. I'm sorry but it's very hard to take these seriously. All of this is a bit like me saying "Bloodspiller could deal 2500 potency and Quietus should heal me to full and give me full MP".

Not really wrong there, but there is a huge a difference between "could" is a very different would since I was speculating at what could have been, and to be fair might as well replace "could" with "should" since I HATE the current iteration of DRK that we have right now.

DRK isn't behind in damage to the point that any of those things you're suggesting wouldn't just boost it through the roof. On top of giving it some pretty ungodly healing. On top of giving it the absolutely most broken invulnerability in the game. On top of it already being the king of personal mitigation.

Pretty sure RDM Embolden(RDM just hates other casters and faux casters as well) and MNK Brotherhood say other wise on the damage part(though this JUST DRK, just remember that PLD, NIN and literally every caster cannot be in the same group as a MNK otherwise it's a DPS loss for MNK, it's just DRK is the more prominent one that comes to mind)... Just like how SCH, DRG, BRD want to point that WAR guaranteed DCH pretty much makes them feel useless for DPS checks as bring a WAR with them is a DPS loss.

What is wrong with point blank AOEs?

If they are weaker than the other tanks PB AoEs than I will have issue with it. In fact, I'm all for giving DRK PB AoE combos(that don't suck in terms of potency).

Or FOS/FOD for that matter?

I just wish they were implemented a lot more smoothly(preferably as burst combos that you did to break up the monotony of spamming Souleater combo).

With TBN even with physical enemies DRKs mitigation is really good. In dungeon trash you've also got Abyssal Drain which is up for every trashpull that tends to range from 1000+ to 2000+ potency heal on an OGCD trigger. In raids you've got magical damage which means you've got 2 extra mitigation cooldowns to work with. LD sucks and should be changed but hardly defines DRKs survivability. He's pretty damn sturdy outside of the flawed invulnerability.

Except once you get TBN you basically either perma-shelved your other CDs unless a fight calls for it, or the fact that you spent the entire expansion doing things new players would normally do and make the healers heal you by not pressing cooldowns because you don't know the difference between Physical Damage and Magical Damage with Dark Mind.

Also quick fix for Dark Mind; bring back Dark Dance with 100% parry rate and have it upgrade into Dark Mind at the level you get Dark Mind.

EDIT: Changed some wording because it sounded a lot more oafish than I meant for it to. I'm being critical but not trying to be a D.

I don't know what you said before you edited you post as I was not awake at the time... so don't feel to bad about it...

[Lammas]

Living Dead is so bad that even if Carve and Spit got the base potency and base MP recovery and had 1200 cure potency equivalent slapped on to, it wouldn't do much to fix it. Though it would give DRK a better flavor of tank though.

You're complaining about DRK survivability, pointing it rather directly to LD, proposing a wild change to C&S of all things and now you're saying it wouldn't even help fix the thing you have a problem with
Of course it wouldn't fix it because you're suggesting changes to something completely unrelated. To fix living dead, the thing that needs changing is living dead, not throwing some random wild self heals on a DPS skill.

If they are weaker than the other tanks PB AoEs than I will have issue with it. In fact, I'm all for giving DRK PB AoE combos(that don't suck in terms of potency).

So, I tried to math the AOEs a bit and didn't see a huge difference when trying to consider the full package of, say, DRK vs GNB. Then I went as far as to ask the math wizards of a FFXIV theory discord how the AOEs pan out vs each other. The answer? Kind of hard to really calculate. In an infinity they all kinda balance out. With no outside buffs considered GNB tends to end up ahead after 20-30 seconds. PLD catches up at about 40 seconds. DRK TBN and WAR self healing allow healers to AOE more which is something that also needs to be considered. WAR and DRK are able to burst a lot early on. And at the end of the day trashpacks shouldn't even live long enough for the damage difference to become noticable.

Pretty sure RDM Embolden(RDM just hates other casters and faux casters as well) and MNK Brotherhood say other wise on the damage part(though this JUST DRK, just remember that PLD, NIN and literally every caster cannot be in the same group as a MNK otherwise it's a DPS loss for MNK, it's just DRK is the more prominent one that comes to mind)... Just like how SCH, DRG, BRD want to point that WAR guaranteed DCH pretty much makes them feel useless for DPS checks as bring a WAR with them is a DPS loss.

RDM and MNK raid buff designs are weirdly exclusive but I thought we were talking about DRKs personal DPS here. As you said yourself, this isn't just a DRK problem. Would I want those changed? Sure, on MNKs and RDMs end.
Returning to the topic at hand however you said Darkside dmg buff could've been 30 % instead of 10 %. That C&S could do three times the damage if does. Are you aware how small the damage difference in a boss fight between DRK and GNB is? Let's look at actual data. I'm not very good at fflogs but assuming I'm looking at this correctly E2S and E4S the difference between the top damage DRK and GNB is less than 5 % for rdps, narrowed down even more for adps. For TEA it's a smigde over 5 % for rdps narrowed down to LESS THAN 1 % difference for adps. I don't think DRK needs to have it's constant 10 % damage buff tripled. I don't think it needs a 900 potency per minute boost with or without that.

Except once you get TBN you basically either perma-shelved your other CDs unless a fight calls for it, or the fact that you spent the entire expansion doing things new players would normally do and make the healers heal you by not pressing cooldowns because you don't know the difference between Physical Damage and Magical Damage with Dark Mind.

I'm not sure where you're shelving your cooldowns or why. The only place where I'd see that being a thing is vs a dungeon boss as they just don't hit very hard. The thing is however that every tank should reserve their longer CDs for the upcoming trashpacks, not just DRK.

I know it's an ideas thread where anyone can suggest whatever they like but I see you complaining about a lot of current things with very little factual base.
DRKs survivability isn't bad, it has really, really good personal mitigation.
DRKs damage isn't bad, it is lower but unless all tanks did exactly identical damage someone has to be and right now it is by a very narrow margin.
DRKs AOE isn't bad, arguments presented above.
Living dead sucks, everyone agrees with that.

I get that something you really used to like being changed to something you now hate sucks. I've been there too. I dunno why I bother even responding here but the biased mudslinging is just getting a little old and a little more objectivity would go a long way.

bonus:

people would probably hate Living Dead consuming their "cool shadow summon for self heal to 100% because mah deeps" which is what a lot of blue DPS want really.

I would indeed hate LD eating my Living shadow at the cost of "muh deeps" as it doesn't make any sense for the invulnerability to do that.
The original idea is also flawed because that would mean I'd have to hold my living shadow and make sure I'd have it up whenever I'm going to LD. It's a bit like suggesting PLD only able to invul during Requiescat and people would indeed hate that.
It would also make LD absolutely terrible for any situation where you need to take more than 1 lethal hit with the invulnerability and with a change like that you'd no longer be able to take 3 tethers from Titania or all 3 hits from E4S tank buster for example.

[DRKoftheAzure]

You're complaining about DRK survivability, pointing it rather directly to LD, proposing a wild change to C&S of all things and now you're saying it wouldn't even help fix the thing you have a problem with
Of course it wouldn't fix it because you're suggesting changes to something completely unrelated. To fix living dead, the thing that needs changing is living dead, not throwing some random wild self heals on a DPS skill.

To be fair self heals on DPS skills would make DRK a hell of a lot cooler. And I am a huge sucker for REALLY COOL things. And for good measure to see if I can come up with an idea on how to fix Living Dead; Living Dead needs to go straight into Walking Dead on activation, can have a maximum number of 5 stacks of Walking Dead, if you have more than 1 stack of Walking Dead you need to be healed by 25% of max HP to reduce number of stacks before it kills you, however it cannot go below 1 stack of Living Dead, and 1 stack means you don't need healing at all until it's about to wear off and if tank swap happens you don't die when it wears off, just need to wait for the healer(s) to heal you.

So, I tried to math the AOEs a bit and didn't see a huge difference when trying to consider the full package of, say, DRK vs GNB. Then I went as far as to ask the math wizards of a FFXIV theory discord how the AOEs pan out vs each other. The answer? Kind of hard to really calculate. In an infinity they all kinda balance out. With no outside buffs considered GNB tends to end up ahead after 20-30 seconds. PLD catches up at about 40 seconds. DRK TBN and WAR self healing allow healers to AOE more which is something that also needs to be considered. WAR and DRK are able to burst a lot early on. And at the end of the day trashpacks shouldn't even live long enough for the damage difference to become noticable.

I was talking no inbetween oGCDs at all as those kinda inflate the numbers a bit too much... Just raw GCDs...

RDM and MNK raid buff designs are weirdly exclusive but I thought we were talking about DRKs personal DPS here. As you said yourself, this isn't just a DRK problem. Would I want those changed? Sure, on MNKs and RDMs end.
Returning to the topic at hand however you said Darkside dmg buff could've been 30 % instead of 10 %. That C&S could do three times the damage if does. Are you aware how small the damage difference in a boss fight between DRK and GNB is? Let's look at actual data. I'm not very good at fflogs but assuming I'm looking at this correctly E2S and E4S the difference between the top damage DRK and GNB is less than 5 % for rdps, narrowed down even more for adps. For TEA it's a smigde over 5 % for rdps narrowed down to LESS THAN 1 % difference for adps. I don't think DRK needs to have it's constant 10 % damage buff tripled. I don't think it needs a 900 potency per minute boost with or without that.

The devs want everything to be viable, I'm just pointing that everything being viable isn't always the case for speedkills, which a lot of people want more speedkills, which isn't wrong to do, it's just even I have to be in the mood for speedkills, and PF is always about speedkills, so luckily I always play something for the few people in the party that join in PF that want speedkills, that doesn't interfere with MNK and/or RDM raidbuffs.

I'm not sure where you're shelving your cooldowns or why. The only place where I'd see that being a thing is vs a dungeon boss as they just don't hit very hard. The thing is however that every tank should reserve their longer CDs for the upcoming trashpacks, not just DRK.

I just look at Edge of Darkness and Flood of Darkness, then Dark Mind, then TBN, and then look at the other tanks and say to myself "The devs have either accidentally or purposefully created a tank job/class that promotes THE WORST POSSIBLE player etiquette."

I know it's an ideas thread where anyone can suggest whatever they like but I see you complaining about a lot of current things with very little factual base.

Does this really surprise you that people are complaining on the forums...?

DRKs survivability isn't bad, it has really, really good personal mitigation.

I covered these thoughts like 2 quotes ago.

DRKs damage isn't bad, it is lower but unless all tanks did exactly identical damage someone has to be and right now it is by a very narrow margin.

Living Shadow exists holding DRK from actually doing better A LOT better.

DRKs AOE isn't bad, arguments presented above.

Covered these thoughs like 6 quotes ago

Living dead sucks, everyone agrees with that.

Actually covered this at the beginning of this post.

I get that something you really used to like being changed to something you now hate sucks. I've been there too. I dunno why I bother even responding here but the biased mudslinging is just getting a little old and a little more objectivity would go a long way.

I honestly don't know either... probably because you want me to calm down and give better, rationally thought out explanations as to why...? Just guessing at this point...

I would indeed hate LD eating my Living shadow at the cost of "muh deeps" as it doesn't make any sense for the invulnerability to do that.
The original idea is also flawed because that would mean I'd have to hold my living shadow and make sure I'd have it up whenever I'm going to LD. It's a bit like suggesting PLD only able to invul during Requiescat and people would indeed hate that.
It would also make LD absolutely terrible for any situation where you need to take more than 1 lethal hit with the invulnerability and with a change like that you'd no longer be able to take 3 tethers from Titania or all 3 hits from E4S tank buster for example.

Or have to Holmgang during IR window to actually get the Invuln part...


Also some advice on quoting on the forums(you don't have to do it if you want to); copy+paste the quote code thing([QUOTE=Lammas;5313488] as an example) to make the responding to quotes a lot more cleaner.