Thank you I wanted to make sure that I wasn't getting it wrong. I did thealc quest just a little before shb came out sooo now that brings to mind though
how was Hythlodaeus able to see Ardbert, I know he said he couldn't make out the shape but could see the color and then said no one else could see it. Thus implying that even Selch didnt see him or even the hint of Ardberts shade.