There's a difference between skepticism and cynicism.
Here, lets put this in context ...
Yoshi has been nothing but transparent with the development of these 2 races after reveal. Because of him we know that both races were only able to reach a presentable state shortly before their reveals (explains why all the Viera had face 1 and why the Hrothgar had the crappy lighting and filters to cover up the poor texture work at that stage). We know why they were added , we know his thoughts on bringing in yet another handsome race with different ears and we know why they decided to release 1 gender for each race. He's painted a very clear picture of what lead to this.
We were told that they wouldn't be able to show ANY head gear unless it was like the mascot heads where it completely replaces the head and that the team would work on adding head gear post release of 5.0. He then shares with us that behind his back and on their free time the devs worked on making 400-500 head gears show on the new races heads even though they had planned to work on this later. They do the media tour where for some reason no youtube "influencer" bothered to ask about this topic but after releasing the benchmark and being asked about it he says these things that are in no way vague. That kinda invalidates skepticism ... we KNOW for a fact he said this as we have this information from an interview. There's nothing to speculate about on that front.
So he has given us no reason to think he isn't being truthful about this information about the new races.
This is where I see things going into cynicism.
And by that I mean "An inclination to question whether something will happen or whether it is worthwhile; pessimism.".
Saying "You don't know, they could just release 1 hair style at the end of the Expansion. This isn't good news" is cynicism. It's taking what we do know (Yoshi saying that they will release more hairstyles and faces for Hrothgar after 5.0 release) disregarding things he said (that the team is prepared for it rn) and taking it to the worst case scenario to discredit the news.
Then you have people also saying things like "Don't take those words as a promise that any added styles will be radically different to the existing ones. It may simply be different combinations of the existing faces and manes" which is the exact opposite of what he said ... this is some kinda nonsense as it assumes he doesn't know the difference between "new hairstyles" and "undoing the decision I made to tie hairs to faces so that I can reuse current hair styles instead of just making new ones".
Cynicism is only used to breed a pessimistic PoV on something to continue a negative narrative or feed negativity. Be it clear or not that negativity will be directed to the Hrothgar in the end.
If you try to push or hold on to the narrative that Hrothgar have bad CC by disregarding any positive news on that front AND ignoring any of the cool and unique CC they do have well also showing no worry for what was said about Viera then .... you're not pushing for support of expanding their CC. Your negativity will just end up pushing a narrative that they are bad/ poorly done/ a waste to people who don't bother to put thought into things.
Like how Meoni gave his opinion on the Races in a video were he shows a clear lack of understanding the basics of the CC to paint Hrothgar in a poor light ("Why can't I use this tattoo option on this other face?" maybe if you didn't play a clean faced catgirl you'd know any race with Tattoos has said tattoos locked to each face). He didn't like it and used his feelings to push a negative take on the race ("they shoulda gone with Male Viera..") which I've seen ripple through out his comment section. He's still doing it. He reported on this news with the assumption that Hrothgar players would be upset to hear ... that their race of choice is gonna get MORE faces and hairstyles instead of getting common ones shared by all. The general take on reddit about this was a sigh of relief that we're getting more and a grunt of discomfort with the conformation that Viera will only get "some" of the shared hairs cause who knows which those will be or how many that is?
Here's an Idea ... lets do a THOUGHT EXPERIMENT!
Certain people here are HOPEFUL for male VIERA (Instagram peeps will get that lol) and are clearly disappointed at the lack of a gender options for the Viera, a race only shown to as women in other games who are shockingly only shown as women in this game.
Lets say Yoshi says this about it tomorrow ...
"Yoshi: In order to get ShB released in the state we wanted to we had to do things this way. But YES, we will be releasing Male Viera and Female Hrothgar after the ShB expansion is completed. Our teams are prepared to take this on"
Would you take this as good news? He said in no uncertain words that this will happen and they're ready to do it ... do you trust him on this?
Or do you say "You don't know, for all we know they're gonna release them on the LAST patch of the LAST expansion before the game is shut down and not allow them to wear more than half the male gear at the time"?
Or do you say " Oooh Poppycock, they could just be putting bunny ears on a Elezen and cat ears on a Femroe, you don't know."
Or do you act like he doesn't know what goes into different genders and say "You can't take his words as a promise. He could just take the tits off of Viera and slap some tits onto the Hrothgar males and say they're now the other genders"?
This would clearly be said to spread or promote negativity about the situation regardless of the news by using any made up worst case scenario to down play said news.
It's not constructive nor productive which is why I ask "whats the point of discussing this if this is what you think?". Cause the only goal I see would be to feed into outrage culture, were you have to assume the worst to get your blood going regardless of the logic behind it.
You wouldn't have to assume that the Hrothgar can fully rearrange their face to allow face changing.
They're set up in a way that every face feature option is the same for each face. The narrow mean looking eyes are eye 3 on all of them. The smallest nose is the same number on all of them. So if you make a mean looking, small nose big chin no fangs having Hrothgar no matter what face you swap to you're gonna get that face's version of those features. That way if you really want to change the details you gotta buy a potion.
Or maybe they do let you basically change everything but the tall/ voice settings. We'll find out.
And it really doesn't matter if some people think it's not fair if that's how SE does it, they are supposed to be seen as a completely different race from others on the very base concept level. Them not having freedom to mix and match hairs with faces AND not having access to any of the non-hrothgar hairs in this game puts them in a situation where either SE demands Hrothgar players pay $10 to change their hair or they're given some freedoms others don't have to make up for it. Maybe fur patterns is the hidden key to this and we get like 50+ patterns to make up for being stuck with our unchanging hair unless we pay $10 to change it?



"
Reply With Quote



