Quote Originally Posted by Mireille View Post
Tanaka created a lot of content in XI, so it would be hard to say that he wasn't responsible for its success with the players. It's funny but now that he is back in XI he is being blamed for killing the very content, Abyssea, that drove so many of its die hard players away. I'd like to see Tanaka develop content for hard core players in XIV. I think he would come up with some great stuff.

I'm not sure I agree completely with Yoshida-san's idea that hard core players are defined by being the first to complete something even though they usually are. I think its more a question of hard core players complete things early in their life-cycle when the content hasn't been figured out or dumbed down to make it accessible. Hard core players are more defined by their desire to face extreme challenges, and being number one out the gate is a secondary consideration.

In XI the events were very challenging, and required leadership skills on the part of the organizers as well as dedication on the part of the participants. Those of you would showed up at every sky/dyna/limbus/salvage your linkshells did know what I mean. Yes we all complained bitterly about the drop rates and kept showing up anyways. I really would like to see events like that in XIV, and if it takes Tanaka to do them then bring him. I'm not suggesting removing Yoshi-P as producer. He's done a great job, and he will continue to do a great job, but his theme park needs more than one vision when it comes to designing the rides.
I agree. But, in respect for Yoshida (and 2.0) i would rather seeing what Tanaka had planned to FFXIV as another game.

I believe that now that they decided the 2.0 is "the FFXIV" then it would be a desmoralization to Yoshida having Tanaka back in charge, even if co-ed...would be like "Hey...we gave you his position but after an year we noticed it was a mistake so the old director is back."...and this would be bad to both Yoshida, that would be labeled as incompetent, and SE itself since this kind of decision would reflect lack of vision of who decided this.

This is why i support the original FFXIV making a return as a spin-off game. It would protect Yoshida and SE and would also reflect the respect SE has for both Tanaka and the players who liked the orriginal FFXIV but didn't like the way the current FFXIV is going...after all they already are different games and when maps change the only similarities between them would be the very same between FFXI and FFXIV...some models.