Why having a dedicated MT and dedicated OT is a TERRIBLE idea

[shao32]

snip

they try to do that all the time and never work, masive homogenization of dps, utility and mitigation will kill tanks identity specially since we want diverse tanks kits what you ask its imposible by how the rotations and stuff works, some tank will be always superior to the others no matter what, holmgang need to be tuned down thats not a secret but that can be balanced easily, what i dont want is every tank having same tools, only the universal skills to fullfill his duty as tanks of course, and all jobs are going to be balanced with the new stuff now in 5.0 so take current WAR and PLD as a argument may not be best.

thats depend of how innefective is take a doube MT-OT, if you loose many stuff for bring double MT-OT, lets say when you have double scholar for example, then you will never want to have 2 of then, specially since what i say except for that especific stuff that separate tanks all of then will have same leves of agro, dps and mitigation in his own way, but his kits will be mre diverse since no matter how much utility PLD have if his partner have similar utility leves, thats saves the other 2 being so focused on utility and can focus on something else, a bit more dps, movility another kind of utility whatever you want.

idk if you see this as a dev perspective, but having to balance against 3 its much more harder that balanced against 1, its save a lot of time and resources since tanks are with healers the most hardest roles to balance.

despite what we saw i doutb we get more tanks since the devs will have a limit of how much jobs are going to be able to handle at the same time, and at minimun we aren't go to get a new tank in 4 years so i dont expect we get more tanks since it will be to much jobs and will affect the quality of the game balance wise speaking.