Living Dead

[Phoenicia]

Living Dead isn't a problem.. it's the effect of Living Dead that's the problem? yeah ok...

You're relying on another player to execute YOUR skill.
The healers has to dump enough heals into you to make sure you survive (pretty important) and not heal you too much so they don't prematurely end the effect of Walking Dead (which would make it inferior to Hallowed/Holmgang)

It's that simple, that is how Living Dead works, therefore Living Dead is the problem.

You're missing the point of my post. It isn't the "effect" of Living Dead that's the problem, it's the rest of the toolkit of the tank that has it.

Living Dead would've been fine on PLD or WAR because they CAN remove the effect by themselves without the "other player". If the tank that has it can meet the survival condition on its own, it would be as strong if not stronger than Hallowed. The problem is, the ability is on the only tank that can't remove it. Hence: The ability itself isn't the problem.