Quote Originally Posted by Kalise View Post
snip
im glad you recognize WAR have stuff that needs to be nerfed like holmgang and shake it off, but i complety disagree, is not a problem that WAR being to strong and the others to weak, not at all, is a problem that WAR has been overbuffed every patch since release bcs WAR mains can't be happy without being the most stronger tank.

on 4.0 WAR was perfectly balanced with the other 2 excep by his dps being a bit low, they have tank swap limitations like the other 2 not being a big dealt since they are still lower compare to DRK and PLD limitations, they only utility was the slashing, holmgang and his entirely defensive kit is the same as right now and they dps rotation was more complex, what happen? they given a the strongest aoe shield mid expansion givin him a powerful utility midexpansion from nowhere something that they din't need broken complety the tank balance, they tank stances limitations removed they have to be especial of course, but PLD and DRK asking for have the same complety ignored or argued we will being to powerful when are actually WAR he most powerfull tank in tank stance, unchained back to being usable so we back again to WAR main pulling when the pull betwen all tanks was similar are more equal and in the end the faceroll rework on his berserk window when DRK suffers severe problems of mitigation and other stuff without being adresed.

right now despite od this "good balance" as phoenicia claims we have DRK is still the most unplayed tank in the game for a far margin and the comon view of the job is despite being able to pull similar numbers they compositions don't offer the same as a WAR-PLD composition, all of this bcs if is not PLD is WAR doing everything better that DRK all of this bcs they overbuffed and rework WAR midexpansion when was DRK the one that need that, DRK have a spot before that, we only really need some potency tweaks to be on par to PLD and the balance would be much much better

Quote Originally Posted by Phoenicia View Post
snip
it's obviously you have diferent point of view of what balance should be done, im not a person that see buff everything to 1 job standars a good thing at all since i saw that creating powercreep problems all the time, the WAR buffs this expansion where unjustified and the clear favoritism around the job insulting.

and as you can see if i think WAR capabilitys are unfairly superior to the other 2 i can't be happy with the "very good balance" we have after WAR cheesing some fights before 4.2 during 2 entire raid tiers.

you understand what you want again, i don't want to WAR being nerfed to the ground at all, i consider WAR 4.0 a perfect status and much more balanced that now and i was not broken or uncapable to do anything, have limitations but his defensive kit was inctact, his dps rotation was solid, his utility was on par and his stances was again ok compared to the other 2, if wanting a proper balance betwen dps, defense, utility and capabilitys betwen all tanks is called WAR hate bcs is as usual the edge then so be it call what you want i don't care anymore, but keep in mind it's insulting bcs we asking for balance and all of then being equal and thats pretty far of what means being a hater.