I wish Gunbreaker would be a DPS class.

[Shurrikhan]

Same could be said for DPS, you don't need new jobs, just massive core changes to existing jobs. Oh hi there MCH.

What fundamental flaws? Tanks are fun, I like tanking, don't be messing with the role in order to appeal to people who don't want to do it.

Isn't that what you just suggested for DPS?

Not all changes that attract new devotees for a given job or role will detract the existing ones. Just as not all changes will manage to attract/retain either...

In the case of tanking especially, there are huge lines of things to potentially add that wouldn't necessarily diminish what little currently goes into performing the role.