Punished For wanting to get stuff done

[Metalwrath]

I'd argue that Cutter's Cry gives new healers more trouble than either of those thanks to the good 'ol non-telegraphed AoEs of the Chimera. This attack is still avoidable though unlike Gold Rush and Burr Burrow, which inflicts a DoT greater than that in BF along with initial damage based on number of stacks. Poison stacks in BF are actually not that bad. Pre 4.0, SCHs would get a little nervous about not having a cleanse at that point, but Lily handles the multiple stacks just fine.

I'm not saying that parties can't or don't get overwhelmed in those two dungeons, but until AV, health bars can stay above a newbie healer's threshold if everyone avoids the bad. In AV against Locksmith and Miser's Mistress, nothing can be done about it, and the healer simply has to step up.

You seem to be forgeting one thing though.Stone Vigil and Brayflox are manditory story dungeons.
Cutters cry is optional.A lot of new players wont do that dungeon and as a result even in leveling roulette if they unlocked on another job it's highly unlikely to appear in duty finder.
AV is also optional.
Brayflox and Stone Vigil are the 2 dungeons a new player is guaranted to have to do and they are known as the 2 pre 50 dungeons that new players struggle the most on to progress story.

[Gemina]

You seem to be forgeting one thing though.Stone Vigil and Brayflox are manditory story dungeons.
Cutters cry is optional.A lot of new players wont do that dungeon and as a result even in leveling roulette if they unlocked on another job it's highly unlikely to appear in duty finder.
AV is also optional.
Brayflox and Stone Vigil are the 2 dungeons a new player is guaranted to have to do and they are known as the 2 pre 50 dungeons that new players struggle the most on to progress story.

I know. Hence why they don't hit as hard a CC or AV. But which dungeons are mandatory, and which ones hit harder goes a little beyond the point I was making though, which is simply just scripted damage healers have to contend with.