Which Atma Crystals go to which Weapon of Zenith

[Trixie_Strider]

Yes, your original post wasn't the best phrased and was difficult for people to understand (hence the incorrect replies). However this clarification you've provided does help a lot, and I'll be honest, I don't know. Doesn't each atma shard have its own colour? Perhaps you can use that to check with the job stone (I think the Atma Archer and Soul of the Bard have the same stone colour) to work out which is which.

Finally, that makes sense, i didn't think aboit that, and it makes sense that the Shard would match the color as the Job Crystal. THANK YOU!!!

[Paladinleeds]

Finally, that makes sense, i didn't think aboit that, and it makes sense that the Shard would match the color as the Job Crystal. THANK YOU!!!

No worries, once we were able to clearly see what you were asking (which someone has correctly stated is lore based rather than gameplay based, and therefore is best asked in the Lore sub-forum. Hopefully a mod moves it over), it made it easier to try and help find the answer. From a gameplay perspective, the atma to which job doesn't matter and you require one of each of the 12 atma's to progress a single weapon to the next stage of the relic questline - so you'll need 10 sets of each, aka 120 atma total, to progress all 10 relic weapons to the next stage (and until your clarification it came across that you were asking on a gameplay perspective how the atma/zenith weapons interacted with the shards, not a lore of which is behind which), which is what others have based their replies off (General Discussion is seen as more gameplay focused, with lore related questions going to Lore), but from a lore standpoint, there's more to discuss.

Anyhow, hopefully you find the answer you seek. I'm interested in it myself, seeing which is which, but as we've stated before, the matches will only be from a lore perspective.

EDIT: I've had a friend of mine (whom I aren't going to name, they don't post on the forums though) reach out to me in-game and they believe the atmas are actually based off the zodiac symbolbs. Given there's 12 zodiacs and 12 atma shard types, this does make sense and may also be what it actually is based off, rather than each tied to a job (10 zodiac/relic weapons, 12 atma types).