Quote Originally Posted by Awha View Post
I do not disagree with the notion that greed all is a busted system
The amount of backpedaling is giving me whiplash.

I have been trying to covey is that Need/greed/pass still alienates certain players just as Greed all does.
The only people who'd be alienated by the old system are people who want to roll things they can't be bothered to bring to the raid. And even then the Greed system existed so it's not like they were without options. There's a reason why people keep saying 'if it's not broken, don't fix it'.
The biggest flaw with the old system was RNG to have the item you wanted show up at all, but it's not like the new system addressed it.

I just do not understand why things must come down to they should stay same since others did not think it was broken.
It's called "democracy". And a bit of "common sense". You're basically complaining things should change despite absolutely no one agreeing with you.
You'd have a much better case if you were campaigning for a token system without defending this new system which you suddenly aren't in favor of.