Quote Originally Posted by Aana View Post
Yet, somehow, as if by magic I rarely ever wipe in dungeons regardless of the party composition.
What I am saying is your claim is weak, for reasons such as:
1) you dont clearly define "good" and "bad" healers
2) the only measurement you're using is the an undefined frequency of wipes.
3) you aren't taking into account other negative factors such as pulling small or under-pulling

Here are some examples of why the items above break your argument:
1) (For the sake of thread irony: ) If someone defines a bad healer as a healer who would heal a tank when they are near full hp, I run into them fairly frequently.

2) If the healer has cure II as an option, but decides cure I is the way to go when the tank makes a large pull and a wipe occurs, it is the healer's fault. It doesnt matter how often it happens.

3) If the tank prevents a wipe from occurring by breaking a section into multiple pulls because he recognized the healer was bad, the healer is still bad. wipes arent the only thing that matters.
Likewise, if the tank is constantly underpulling, that doesnt mean the healer is good, it means the tank is bad.