Stormblood Expansion was a mistake...

[Vidu]

That being said i still enjoy Stormblood and the content.They also need to stop being lazy and recycling glamors and releasing it as new content.A lot of Stormblood gear is reskins.

...all the crafted leveling gear in HW were re-skins of ARR-gear. Its nothing new that we're getting re-skins of existing gear. Some of the dedicated glamour-gear we got in HW was a re-skin of ARR-stuff (that bard-coat and some casters-robes made into lvl1-non-restricted items).
You probably gonna call me out on whiteknighting the devs or something, but I can totally see that their art department has limitations aswell and wouldnt call them lazy for re-using models.

[Malzian]

simplifying all jobs to a level so even bad players can reach high numbers (looks at redmage).

Fixed that for you... Seriously, can we PLEASE get past the phase of "playing casually = playing badly". Not all casual players are bad, not all "hardcore" players are always good. Let's stop measuring the player base on the achievements of the World First groups, you don't hold people playing pick-up basketball games to the standard of pro players. They may not be able to play on the Pro level for one reason or another, but that does not mean those people are bad players.

[Kazgrel]

ITT: Comparing an xpac still in progress to a complete xpac...

I can only imagine how bad this sort of rhetoric was 2 years ago (I skipped 3.1 entirely due to burnout).

[Wilan]

From class/job adjustments [...] the game no longer is fun to play

Somebody didn't try to main Paladin in Heavensward.

[MysticDreamer]

I am enjoying this expansion just like how I also enjoyed heavensward.Ast is far better off than it was before.Remember heavensward ast? That was a nightmare.I still stuck with it cause I had hope it would improve which it greatly did and I am happy with ast now.Only thing I would like is for lightspeed to be more reliable.It would help in noct sect when we don't have regen.Its still a little difficult to heal in this sect especially when things are going bad and you blow off your cooldowns.Having a consistent lightspeed would make healing in this sect easier.

[Airget]

ITT: Comparing an xpac still in progress to a complete xpac...

I can only imagine how bad this sort of rhetoric was 2 years ago (I skipped 3.1 entirely due to burnout).

True, comparing Stormblood now to HW when HW had content like POTD which for me was the MVP of the entire expansion. Heck even Diadem was fun for it's limited release and testing the waters at said content. From the teases we got for Eureka I am hopeful that it will turn into what Diadem should of been.

[Zeonx]

I think they should release Defender for Tank.

Revamp DRK to be a DPS give it other skills my cousin said tanking on drk is a pain now not like it was in heavensward.

[Vidu]

Revamp DRK to be a DPS give it other skills my cousin said tanking on drk is a pain now not like it was in heavensward.

They're not gonna change the role of a job...

And to me DRK was a "pain" as tank in HW and its still a "pain" in SB - I see why people are upset since it recived some major changes, but its still very playable and still very able to fullfill its tank-role. Holding hate is a non-issue and healing a DRK stayed an issue, so...
I understand people wanting their old DRK back, but its not as if the job is broken as it is right now.

[TheCount]

They're not gonna change the role of a job...

And to me DRK was a "pain" as tank in HW and its still a "pain" in SB - I see why people are upset since it recived some major changes, but its still very playable and still very able to fullfill its tank-role. Holding hate is a non-issue and healing a DRK stayed an issue, so...
I understand people wanting their old DRK back, but its not as if the job is broken as it is right now.

Its a shadow of its former self and it feels badly designed now, you may as well call it broken because the only way in which it is not broken is that it can still do all the encounters. Only by doing so you'll have the constant reminder that choosing your DRK instead of the other two options is a detriment to the group

[Fynlar]

Also where do people get the idea that MCH is this crazy RNG-fiesta class? It's not even remotely comparable to AST.

Every time you're firing your first two primary GCD attacks without ammo, it sure feels like RNG to me (which is rather often, considering you can't just have ammo up all the time). If anything you're playing the RNG more frequently than AST does, because at least with them their card draw is only every 30 seconds.