4.0 Warrior Feedback

[P4X0R10N]

No, it would still be 25% increase, since you decrease by 20%
350*1.25*0.8 = 350

No, they should be one skill that changes according to your stance, like Equilibrium.

No, they're not. Steel Cyclone is your level 45 skill, while Decimate is your level 60 skill. If Steel Cyclone was a skill that behave differently depending on your stance, then you could learn a totally different skill at level 60.

NB : You can bypass the character limit by editing your post

Fc and inner beast is the same as equilibrium. They are TWO skills which share one button.

Yes, you do learn fc and decimate after steel cyclone and ib, but the way they function together is identical to the way eq functions.

There's nothing stopping SE from adding more skills to warriors if it's needed. So if that's your issue then there's no need to tie that in with how fc, ib, steel cyclone and decimate currently function.

[Reynhart]

Fc and inner beast is the same as equilibrium. They are TWO skills which share one button.

They were two skills that take two slots in your toolkit.
Back in 3.x, PLD and DRK always has access to 32 skills, regardless of their stance. WAR always has only 30 skills available, since each stance would prevent 2 skills to be used.

I can't tell whether or not you're just being purposely dense.

So, it doesn't bother you that every job learn a totally new skill at 54 and 60 while WAR only gain a replacement, resulting in two less skills in their toolkit ?

[P4X0R10N]

And why do all tanks have to have EXACTLY the same number of skills available at all times in order for them to be balanced?

What is your reasoning?

[P4X0R10N]

And further, abilities are added usually during expansions and stuff, ie dungeons, raids, etc, are tuned around those abilities.

So I'm not sure how you could "merge" ib and fc for instance without throwing off that balance and tuning. If fc and ib and steel cyclone and decimate were "merged", would warriors get replacement abilities for lvl 50 to 60?

You can't cuz that stuff is done, and you ought to not mess with it. Would you give new abilities to wars lvl 60 to 70?

Well "merging" these abilities is not needed is it? SE could add new abilities now if they wanted.