Theorycrafting doesn't mean it can't be true. If people are providing mathematical evidence regarding rotation potency, until shown to be untrue, I have to side with it.

We've seen the potency, DRKs rotation is braindead...1 combo. Only thing we're not sure on right now is whether or not 50 blood generates from BN in general, after you take some dmg, or only if the shield is used up. Since Q is just a trash pull move, BN is meh regardless, BS is not as potent over all as Scourge and is a GCD...research by others is showing our dps goes down. PLD's is going way up. All this does is shift the ideal comp from WAR/DRK to PLD+WAR/DRK. They didn't balance at all. They just put a different tank in the spotlight. If you're going to make PLD the DPS king fine... I play all 3 tank jobs...but don't give them the most Mitigation, Self Healing, Group Mitigation, -and- the top DPS on top of it. It's not balanced, and it's going to create the same problems with DRK and WAR that PLD has had.