It's amusing when people who are very obviously casual players (nothing wrong with being a casual player, games are about having fun after all) try to act like they have any grounds in the debate about WHM in 4.x. The job will probably be fine in the story content and whatnot, but it is very obviously a dead job for Savage/Extreme content and beyond. Anyone who actually does that content can see that with but a single glance at the new buttons and mechanics of the job.