what I hope for 4.0 Battle System

[javid]

Roles" are, in the end, mere specializations for which a degree of primary capabilities (damage-dealing in the case of any fight cleared by killing the enemies, or healing in any fight cleared by topping off a given NPC, etc.) is sacrificed to allow a higher degree of capacity for handling secondary functions (anything tactic that improves your raid's ability to clear the encounter that is not a direct, or primary, capacity, such as by reducing the ratio of incoming to outgoing damage) or tertiary functions (anything that improves upon those secondary functions while not directly contributing to them).
This.

Let's start... you simply state your premise but don't prove it. So let's have you prove for one how the concepts I suggested were anything to do with your concerns?

But let me reiterate some of the point's I made with a real example. Alex savage turn 6 first mob casted a spell that needed to be silenced. Pld, sch, nin, mnk, brd and mch are the only jobs that can fullfil that requirement. However if you've ever done this fight the job that were least equipped for the ROLE in order of difficulty were mnk ( just no....), sch (bc selene is unpredictable), pld (bc spiritwithin animation is long), nin (could mess up your rotation especially your proper opener) and lastly brd and mch tied for difficulty. The reason this is an example of role playing and an example of non direct dps mechanics yet vital to overall dps is embedded in the experience of that fight.

The smoothest and the fastest clears for that boss (and the entire raid) were the ones that emphasizes the importance of fulfilling that role (among others). Aka role playing