Quote Originally Posted by Reynhart View Post
What I feel is that it would have also been the same in 2.x if we already three tanks.
Even before the "shifting" in raid requirement, WAR would already have a secured spot while PLD and WAR would compete for the remaining spot.
If you truly believe that then I think we have to presume that PLD is just bad. I don't necessarily think it is (personally I like 60 PLD), but if it is so bad that you would honestly consider running double WAR over a single Pally, there is something intimately wrong with Paladin, not with Warrior. I mean, if 0 people played SMN because its CDs were bad (and far more people play BLM than SMN raiding now) would you just say 'Well BLM is OP and SMN is crap so we need to nerf BLM'? It's apples to oranges, but the comparison holds. If Paladin really is that bad it needs a dramatic shift to become good. Warrior doesn't need to be dragged down to its level.