I would be okay with it if it gave whatever gear level that Palace of the Dead is giving that patch. It would be great as a "catch-up" mechanic and would genuinely allow players to somewhat queue for older content, but it definitely shouldn't be easy to get and it would require level sync. This way, it's not relevant for players who probably played the ever loving piss out of that content when it came out, and it would help close the gear gap between patches. I would have a hard time justifying it past that purpose as having it give some of the best gear in the game or just under the best gear in the game is definitely not the way to go.

I would also like to point out Deliciou5 that shoving your opinion down other people's throats is not going to make you popular when you already have a very loathed suggestion for the game.