Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
Yep, the attitude needs to change that striving for improvement of yourself and others and being required to do more than the absolute minimum is "bullying", like you try to say it is. This is part of the reason people in this game are so bad. Nothing requires them to improve by design. There's no real difficulty curve. So now we, the players, should also stop requiring improvement? How about no?
Excuse me? I need you to point out where I say asking people to improve is bullying? Quote it. Bold it. I implicitly stated that if you are making other people feel less than yourself, THAT is bullying. But you're not asking other players to improve, are you? You're telling them to. You're requiring it. You're demanding it, and you come off as belligerent doing so. This is not ok. If you want to talk about being considerate of others, then I think you need to reflect on telling people what to do is poor etiquette and bad manners. This is something MOST people are taught as children.

Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
For the umpteenth time, the fact that healer DPS is not strictly and numerically required to beat bosses has nothing to do with this. Healers should absolutely be told to DPS. If they cannot handle DPSing and healing, they should either move on to another role or accept that they are a mediocre healer. Don't try to make sub-par play acceptable, we have enough bad players as it stands.
It has EVERYTHING to do with this. Do you have such pomp that you feel what you say is law? The golden standard? Your issue is you feel healers than only heal are performing sub-par. It's really isn't complicated. The healing DPS contribution required to clear an instance is currently set at 0%. Anything greater than this number means the healer is doing more than what is required of them to complete an instance. If the DPS number is set at, let's say 70% and they indeed to put forward that 70%, they too are doing what is required of them. But let's say they are not, and their contribution is hovering 60%. This means the tank and/or the healer have to make up the loss. This means they are doing more than what is required. It means they are "carrying" the DPS members of their group assuming the DPS are deliberately entering instances with sub-par performances.

I get it, you feel players who only put forth exactly what is needed are mediocre at best, and that's fine. You want players to strive to be better than they were yesterday, and this too is perfectly ok. But to feel like you're carrying a healer through an instance because they don't DPS? That is utterly ridiculous.

Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
But. They. Are. They are playing on a level of a DPS autoattacking, or a tank spamming Flash. That is literally what a heal-only healer is doing. The absolute, bare, minimum required contribution. That is the very definition of inadequate.
Read the last clause again. Then look up the definition of "adequate". Then also tell me how many times you failed to clear something because the healer didn't DPS. You really need to understand that YOUR requirements are not the same as the game's requirements to complete something. If you want to be Yoda, and coach up healers to perform to your standards, you are more than free to do so.

Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
By the twelve, no, it's not. By your definition, criticism is bullying. Stop trying to paint people who want and require more than the minimum contribution from people as "bullies". You're basically name-calling because you have no arguments.
Again, I am pretty sure I made it clear what bullying is. Nothing wrong with criticism if it is constructive. Your criticism is anything but that. As for the arguments, in my last response to you, I tried to be nice and I tried to be civil. Yet, you continue to press on by quoting my statements. Why is this? Especially with a post that was clearly an attempt to bring some harmony among all of us no matter your view? It sure in hell isn't because I have no argument, or because they are weak. You defend not being a bully so strongly, even though I never called you one. Speaks tons dude.

Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
There aren't, and you haven't even tried to provide any. Also, pretty much all other reasons people have provided here or elsewhere reduce to either or both of laziness and selfishness, including the unwillingness to improve.
I shouldn't have to provide any. Nor should any healer who is uncomfortable. Do you know this feeling? Being uncomfortable? It is NOT something you brush aside. What you likely consider the weakest of the these arguments is quite possibly the biggest reason why you shouldn't press the issue, and why I defend these players as much as I do. If someone says they are uncomfortable, it STOPS right there. THAT is what is called common courtesy. If that is not ok with you, boot the healer, get a new one and move on.

Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
On the contrary, what you are doing is counter-productive. You are advocating sub-par playstyle as acceptable, or even "great". That's not gonna help anyone improve, because it allows people to sit comfortably on their minimum contribution thinking they are good players.
I never said the minimum contribution makes a healer great. Is this what you do to make a point? Reword things to shape them in your favor? And you tell me I don't have an argument? Have I not clearly stated I encourage healer DPS? The whole reason why I am here is because I am telling you that telling other players what to do is NOT ok.

Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
The elite healers are those who maximize DPS in the hardest fights the game provides, not those who DPS at all, your definitions make no sense. Again, you cannot be a good or even "great" healer without utilizing Cleric and your offensive spells. Hell, you can't even properly learn to heal without DPSing, as I've pointed out multiple times in this and/or other threads.
Just love how you left out where I said good and great healers also DPS. Your arguments are literally getting weaker the more you make.

Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
This is about the only thing in this entire post I will agree with. I will absolutely have patience and understanding for someone who actually tries, because that means they are willing to improve, instead of expecting the rest of the party to carry them. Willingness to improve is step 0 to becoming a good player. And yes, failure is crucial to learning, because continued success makes people complacent.
Bravo! You are capable of more than indifference. Apply that to your "criticism" and you just might garner success with improving the game play of others.

Quote Originally Posted by _slowpoke_ View Post
As long as you keep up this nonsensical, argument-free defense of bad play in the name of not criticizing people for said play, no, we're not gonna get along. Please stop, you're not helping.
I don't remember defending bad play. I only remember telling you that your definition of bad play is a crock of shit. G'day to you sir.