Players Who Don't pull their weight.

[Kallera]

Of I am failing a mechanic in a fight, or unable to perform my role in a fight, am I doing it intentionally or not? am I just unfamiliar with it, or am I trolling? Should the long time player be punished for not remembering the nuances of every fight in the game, or going on hiatus?

The problem with this, is that you have to define where it ends and hope it doesn't start killing legit parties. If it is somewhere south of "speedrun", You had better be satisfied with the minimum of that effort or else we are going to have this conversation all over again, with less people in game.