Quote Originally Posted by Wintersandman View Post
Next when the WoL looked reluctant to have a drink with him I was thinking there was something definitely wrong.

Then an FC member pointed out to me around the grand melee that even Thancred was showing some reluctance.

Lastly, what was he muttering after Nidhogg flew away.

He reminds me of Littlefinger.
I've seen the WoL's reaction to his offer for a drink thrown around quite a lot as "evidence" that there's something going on with him, but if you read the description for the quest it says quite clearly in that instance you're thinking of Minfilia and don't feel like celebrating after what you've just found out.

Also, Thancred's reluctance was due to him feeling the Ishgardians are relying too much on the WoL; he actually says Aymeric isn't very good at hiding his emotions, though he admires his honesty.

And I'm surprised by how many people think Aymeric is going to throw Estinien away. I don't think he murmured something sinister at the end of the MSQ - it actually says he made some sort of "oath", and I don't see him giving up on his friend just yet. I saw significant parallels between Aymeric shooting Estinogg and the first time they properly met (from Tales of the Dragonsong War.)

I know a lot of people see him as being too "perfect" and are convinced there's a darker/ evil/ different side to his nature we've not seen, but I think we've already seen both sides of him. If you can't see the flaws in his character, you haven't been paying much attention.