Tank Balance - Thordan EX 7-WAR 1-WHM Clear (Really SE?)

[Reynhart]

No one likes a nerf, the argument will be drk and pld need a buff. But I did notice that some of the people defending warrior are warriors. I see the same reaction from warriors in my ls, go figure.

Like most people, I don't really like jobs to be nerfed.
But, from the way I see it, if "all WAR" can clear as fast as usual setup and "all PLD"/"all DRK" can't clear, or can clear much slower, which should be intended, since they're tanks, the wrong numbers should be on WARs.

A little reminder, though. I have nothing personal against WAR, I find the job really fun to play, even though it's my least favorite tank. Should PLD or DRK stand undoubtedly above, I would do the same to point out the flaws. And if the next raid tier is specifically designed for PLD, and DRK is left out for an ideal PLD+WAR setup, I'll do the same too.

Thordan is mechanic heavy and had very low DPS checks so I have no doubt I will be able to clear it.

That didn't really answer the question
So, let's change it a little. If you're only able to clear it much slower. Would it mean that WAR is too fast or PLD is too slow, and why ?

[Awful]

Like most people, I don't really like jobs to be nerfed.
But, from the way I see it, if "all WAR" can clear as fast as usual setup and "all PLD"/"all DRK" can't clear, or can clear much slower, which should be intended, since they're tanks, the wrong numbers should be on WARs.?

The reason being why this group cleared like how they did is how burst is set up in this fight 1 min and 30 sec cds are in huge favor for this fight and the DPS checks are low so you can faceroll everything while mitigating and doing mechanics. It's more about player skill and how if you're a good player in the hands of 200-210 gear with a 205-210 weapon Thordan is a cake walk. We outgear most of the content you have to remember this is a "catch up" patch where everyone and their mother can get a set full of 210 via vertical progression.

Also nothing needs to be nerfed wars are in a great place as being the token OT, Drks and Plds can fill the MT role Thordan is a GREAT fight for Paladins as people who wanna be tanky and take advantage of paladins mitigation will have a blast. It's my favorite fight to tank on at the moment.