Quote Originally Posted by eagledorf View Post
That would be terrible because if it's balanced at an equal amount of gear, that tank would be overpowered during the middle part of progression when the DPS get weapons first
Why ?
Quote Originally Posted by eagledorf View Post
Just give up on this stupid insistance that PLD is the pure tank when we all know it would be game-breaking to actually make them a measurably better tank than the other two and increase Paladin's DPS
Again, why ? For the increase "tankiness" part. The "increase DPS" part, for me, is not a good solution if we want each tank to be really different than the others.

It's a good thing to explain your reasoning, and even give examples, of why something would be "game-breaking" or "break the balance".