Quote Originally Posted by Ninimo_Babamo View Post
People really aren't answering your question, so I will.
You kind of didn't... OP just wanted to know who does more DPS (straight up on a dummy it sounds like)

If you put a WHM and SCH on a dummy for 10 minutes a SCH would do more overall damage because they have better mana regeneration and a WHM would simply run out of juice.

AST isn't onpar with either because it's not its function. At the cost of its own DPS it buffs others (Lightspeed shouldn't really be used for DPS because it reduces DPS potency...). WHM has fluid aura, PoM, Aero III, and Assize which all make a sizeable difference to overall damage done. WHM also has more MP regen than AST inherently though an AST may be lucky with Ewer draws on a dummy.