What if Tank classes could only meatshield?

[FallenWings]

Irrelevant response for actual current content since that is more or less what will ultimately happen regardless of which Tank design(under the concept of the Trinity) is in place. When actual aggro management and CD usage is still required(ala primary roles of the TANKS in the trinity) is where the questions are relevant.

Some minor nitpicking, MNK can't do it due to positionals making it unable to hold aggro optimally against other classes, casters getting interrupted from basic auto-attacks, other class mechanics that will get @%#*, etc ...

I should've probably clarified this earlier as well, these ideas are not something I would personally propose to actually be implemented, but to invoke discussion among(amongst? lolwords) the tank community, see the community's views on what they want, and if its what we really want with the confusion in the ongoing discussion on the current meta.