My only Issue with Heavensward

[OMEGA_HACK]

You do have to consider that Esoterics can only be obtained with a level capped job. The current set-up allows you to gear up other jobs instead of restricting you to one type, and is far more convenient. If this were needed to be implemented, penalties to the amounts of Esoterics you receive per completion of dungeons would need to be significantly reduced; about less than half of the current rewards for completion would suffice, due to being able to obtain more than our current weekly cap. Otherwise, it does sound nice on paper. In practice? It might be a hassle.

I'm not understanding why it [the amount of EsoTomes received per dungeon] would need to be reduced. If you are playing on DRG and complete a dungeon you would only get Eso Tomes of Melee Combat and if you were playing on AST you would only get Eso Tomes of Healing, etc etc. Roulette would base the bonus Eso Tomes on which ever job you were on when you queued for the roulette. It wouldn't really be restrictive in any sense besides "If you want to gear up a tank you have to play a tank". Which in turn will only help the community since it would rule out people who play a tank to gear a healer then jump into harder content as the healer with not as much endgame experience as say someone who geared up a healer as a healer. Because sadly some bad players are a result of this. They lack the literal time playing said job because they have geared it up using another job altogether.

I should also note that the Tomes cannot be combined; like I mentioned earlier in one of my first posts that Eso Tomes of Melee Combat would only be able to be used on DRG, NIN, or MNK gear, while Eso Tomes of Healing would only be able to be used on AST, WHM, or SCH gear. So reducing the amount earned doesn't make much sense it would still take 16 weeks to fully gear up a job however with a setup like this players would be able to gear up to 5 jobs completely in the 16 weeks vs the current 80 weeks to gear up 5 jobs (the system we have now). Do keep in mind that means that you have have to run a EX dungeon 12 times to cap ONE type of Tome (roughly 6-8 hours of play time). If you are gearing up 5 jobs then you have to run those dungeons 60 times a week (roughly 30 hours of play time a week << this is a HARDCORE player as many people with management jobs + families don't have 30 hours of free time available a week). So people obtaining a goal like that will be slim; however, it will allow most people to gear up at least two jobs using Tomes under this new proposed method.

So in short: on paper and in practice it would make sense. ;-)

[Kaze3434]

snip
So in short: on paper and in practice it would make sense. ;-)

what adam means is that with your setup, people would be limited if they dont have certain roles leveled up. case in point; say i wanted to gear up my healer, but i dont have it lvl 60. under the current system, i can get gear for something i dont have max lvl while still lvling it up, so long as i have any other job at 60. in yours, i am SOL unless i have the job at 60, and then there are the time constraints with getting tomes for the roles i would/do have at 60. people would burn out faster.

EDIT; also, remember, while ninja is a melee job, its gear is dex, so it would be possible to abuse your system for the accesories by having brd/mch at 60 and nin. use the melee tomes for left side, and the range tomes for right.

[AdamFyi]

I'm not understanding why it [the amount of EsoTomes received per dungeon] would need to be reduced.

By having mutiple tomes with entirely separate caps, you're essentially allowing players to obtain a total of 1,800 Tomestones of Esoterics every week. Our current weekly cap is only 450 Esoterics tomes. Your suggestion quadruples this weekly cap, and as such, is imbalanced. To counter this, you would need to either implement a hard global cap on all the tomes collectively, or significantly reduce the amount of Esoterics awarded per completion.

Again, nice on paper, imbalanced in practice.