Thoughts on level 60 scholar ability?

[Benedictrine]

Very sure. The argument of HPS is irrelevant in most content because you're factoring in non existent heals by thinking like that. I'm not bible thumping the skill, but there's multiple points to be had. Unfortunately, characters are too limited to make all of them and explain in actual detail. SCH should be played preventatively for the most part, e.g mitigation of raid dmg through succor/adlo/soil in some cases, and your pet factoring into this by topping people off to avoid mana and skill waste. Embrace+physick macro only comes into play during mana crunch/times where playing preventatively isn't necessary or optimal. My biggest problem with all of this was the sheer amount of negativity towards the skill. Don't get me wrong, I can see the skill becoming less useful in comfortable content like static raid content, and it's not useful at all in 4 man.