Should we be limited to only one craft class?

[Raistlin]

is called economy, is useless to have a craft if so many people have it. I want people to be limited, coz if not, we will have 12381270 weavers, 238901273 leathercrafters 12391786 goldsmithings, and u will NEVER have benefits crafting something.

Too much offer -> benefits limited


DNO can u modify your poll? you are not impartial:

LIKE this if you WANT TO KEEP the craft system in place where you can level each class as free as you want. Positive sentence

LIkE this if you want SE to LIMIT us to one class per character then if you want to rank another craft up you must pay for a mule Negative sentence

is like i post:

LIKE this if you WANT TO KEEP the craft system in place where every one can level up your crafting, limiting how much u can sell. Negative sentence

LIkE this if you want SE to LIMIT to maximize only 1 craft to make your class feel more unique and balancing economy Positive sentence

Just ask if they want LIMITED or not, dont add your opinions on a poll.

[DNO]

is called economy, is useless to have a craft if so many people have it. I want people to be limited, coz if not, we will have 12381270 weavers, 238901273 leathercrafters 12391786 goldsmithings, and u NEVER will have benefits crafting something.

Too much offer -> benefits limited


DNO can u modify your poll? you are not impartial:

LIKE this if you WANT TO KEEP the craft system in place where you can level each class as free as you want. Positive sentence

LIkE this if you want SE to LIMIT us to one class per character then if you want to rank another craft up you must pay for a mule Negative sentence

is like i post:

LIKE this if you WANT TO KEEP the craft system in place where every one can level up your crafting, limiting how much u can sell. Negative sentence

LIkE this if you want SE to LIMIT to maximize only 1 craft to make your class feel more unique and balancing economy Positive sentence

Just ask if they want LIMITED or not, dont add your opinions on a poll.

Its not an opinion its a fact. it you can not rank/master/level all crafts on one toon YOU NEED A MULE if you want to rank more then one.

Why is that hard to understand? FF11 the last MMO made you pay for it to craft how is this my opinion?

the tread will NOT be changed!

[DNO]

I think it might be a good idea to limit players to maybe 2 or 3 crafts, but limiting to just 1 is too much. Perhaps we could group crafts together into crafting "fields" ... like a field of study. Lots of crafts rely on others. For example, BSM relies on a lot of GLD items, so it would make sense for them to go together (and maybe ARM in there as well). Food and alchemy would go together nicely too. As would CRP, WVR, and tanner. the worst part of that idea would be that one group only has 2 crafts, but I don't know the system well enough to know which two should be grouped together out of the groups of three.

Or just let us have 2 crafts uncapped...

Crafts that are not our chosen path should be allowed to go to... say...50% or 60% of the max imo

What about the people who have 3-4 crafts at max? those ranks are gone now?

[Cairdeas]

If they are going to keep the crafters as levelable classes they shouldn't be limited to anything. Especially if as they hinted at some of them might be getting a few new skills to use actually in combat.

[DNO]

If they are going to keep the crafters as levelable classes they shouldn't be limited to anything. Especially if as they hinted at some of them might be getting a few new skills to use actually in combat.

Right that my point. its 100k from 49 to 50 and that money you spent to rank up and time. now i wont be able to use everything? then i want my SP back and i want to put it into something esle.

[Zkieve]

is called economy, is useless to have a craft if so many people have it. I want people to be limited, coz if not, we will have 12381270 weavers, 238901273 leathercrafters 12391786 goldsmithings, and u will NEVER have benefits crafting something.

Too much offer -> benefits limited

In ffxi people still had a load of crafts maxed on a different char.The only difference is you paid the extra money, i for one had smith maxed on my char and was trying to cap weaver on my mule , wich i never completed becouse i didnt want to reroll sub crafts over and over again.

this have nothing to do with economy, if people want to have multiple crafts maxed, they will have multiple crafts maxed.hardcore crafters anyways, the rest this wont affect in anyway i can see.

The issue here is this is money maker mechanic and a bad move because since people lived with it in 11 they think they can pull the same crap here.

Edit; the only REAL way to make it so only few people have some crafts maxed is to make the crafting processes difficult or long.Capping chars to one craft is meaningless regarding this.(for hardcorecrafters anyways who are the ones mostly affected by this)

[Leknaat]

I'd object to SE limiting crafting to one class if it means that I have to put my gear up for repairs. The reason why /I/ levelled my crafts was to make sure I never had to /sh in Ul'dah for repairs.

[DNO]

In ffxi people still had a load of crafts maxed on a different char.The only difference is you paid the extra money, i for one had smith maxed on my char and was trying to cap weaver on my mule , wich i never completed becouse i didnt want to reroll sub crafts over and over again.

this have nothing to do with economy, if people want to have multiple crafts maxed, they will be .hardcore crafters anyways, the rest this wont affect in anyway i can see.

Great point and as you said it a million times it can not be more true. people will still rank more then one craft but you people are fighting to ask SE to charge you for it and lose some ranks on some peoples crafts. thats not right.

[DNO]

I'd object to SE limiting crafting to one class if it means that I have to put my gear up for repairs. The reason why /I/ levelled my crafts was to make sure I never had to /sh in Ul'dah for repairs.

Thanks you. the game NEEDS more crafters because of repairs. thats what my OP is about. Limit crafters then limit the need for crafters in taking the repair system out.

[Raistlin]

Its not an opinion its a fact. it you can not rank/master/level all crafts on one toon YOU NEED A MULE if you want to rank more then one.

Why is that hard to understand? FF11 the last MMO made you pay for it to craft how is this my opinion?

the tread will NOT be changed!

U are totally impartial to create a poll like that, that all. Ok is a fact that if u want to level up all crafts to 100,u will need a mule, then add too that your class will feel more unique, and add on the other one that if we all can level up all crafts, economy as crafter will be a shit, and crafters will never win money more than spended.

That are facts too, but u are using what you want to tip the balance.


is too dificult to ask this?:
Like this if u want to be limited to level up only 1 craft
Like this if u dont want to be limited to level up only 1 craft

stop trying to influence on a poll.