3.0: Elemental Weakness/Resistance?

[Yukiko]

This will result in people excluding certain classes and will make the Duty Finder a big risk factor when it comes to clearing content.

Thats already happening, have you never heard of "BLM burn strategy" or leavers in DF just after joining?

Almost no damage? Playing with fear to argument is a bad way! You do not know how they may implement it, there are way too many possibilities!
One way as example is to give the player resistances and not the boss, at least the players have more choises then and can prepare for bossfights.
Other way is to not make bosses immune to elements but even then there is not a single job or class with just "one" element, seriously does it really hurt that much "not" to use "one" element in your rotation?

Edit: Furthermore, it allows new classes/jobs with supporting abilities who can negate elemtal resistance as we seen in older FF games.

[Mardel]

Other way is to not make bosses immune to elements but even then there is not a single job or class with just "one" element, seriously does it really hurt that much "not" to use "one" element in your rotation?

Edit: Furthermore, it allows new classes/jobs with supporting abilities who can negate elemtal resistance as we seen in older FF games.

Yes it does hurt to not use one element in your rotation. Fire > Fire > Fire > PROC (Fire 3) ~ you get the idea.... so let's leave fire out of my rotation for this ifrit... oh wait.

If they assign elements to melee attacks then it will mess up the entire game and require a full overhaul of every job. Elements aren't going to come back in terms of boss weakness any time soon. IF it did it would be "fake" elemental damage. Something akin to how blm handles fire now or how "Fist of Fire" gives attack bonus (not fire elemental bonus).

The supporters of elemental damage need to understand that SE is not going to go back and re-develop something that isn't broken. As a modder I understand this, making one change to a job takes a lot of re-work/re-balance; which is not worth doing in this situation. They don't need elemental damage to exist, they can simply make the lore say something like: "Manipulate the mana to take the shape of _____."

[Amberion]

Snip!

Or you know, instead of reworking the entire game, they could add potions or mixtures to alchemy that changes damage type. Make crafters actually a needed part of the game.

EDIT: Was talking about melee classes there btw.

[Mardel]

Or you know, instead of reworking the entire game, they could add potions or mixtures to alchemy that changes damage type. Make crafters actually a needed part of the game.

EDIT: Was talking about melee classes there btw.

They already said they won't make a class that uses items, but if you mean by just new useful items outside main-stat pots they would still have to make them better than the straight main stat increase.
On a job related note if they made a Chemist class it would merely have names that sounds like it utilizes items, but really wouldn't. Like "Ether Shot"

[Yukiko]

Yes it does hurt to not use one element in your rotation. Fire > Fire > Fire > PROC (Fire 3) ~ you get the idea.... so let's leave fire out of my rotation for this ifrit... oh wait.

You sound like a BRD who is whining about the 20% less dmg from songs...

[Dwill]

You sound like a BRD who is whining about the 20% less dmg from songs...

That has got nothing to do with what he said. He was pointing out that with how the game is currently balanced and with the current jobs/classes mechanics, asking for elemental weaknesses to be taken into consideration would require an overhaul of quite a few game mechanics. The damage system isn't broken by any stretch of the imagination so an overhaul like this is less than likely going to happen.

I remember when they took these away from us, it was a 'wonderful' surprise on the beta forums. Yoshida wrote a long post about why, and balancing, etc..mostly said, iirc, to prevent class stacking that was a big issue in 1.0.

However, I would have preferred if they kept it but figured out an alternative way to prevent class stacking. Meh, people are gonna do it anyway..and they do. Folks denying it I guess forgot about the WP spamming with 'blm only' and then we had the Brayflox spamming with "BLM, BRD" only. But hey...what do I know?

Another huge issue with that is that certain jobs would have been heavily disadvantaged (Black Mage, the more obvious one) and other not at all( Summoner whose majority of their damage is Unaspected).

[Mardel]

^ Thanks for the support Dwill and for understanding the point I was trying to make. (I type on here while I'm on the down time from teaching.)

You sound like a BRD who is whining about the 20% less dmg from songs...

Nope, I never whine about the damage reduction. It's a fair trade off and doesn't take anything away from my rotation. It's not like I'm forced to spam heavyshot and not put dots up; this makes it an entirely different situation.

[Yukiko]

snip

Thats when you assume ifrit will become immune to fire!
You seem to assume a lot, because thats not what i had said.
And sorry, but you really sound like one of those Bards...

[Dwill]

Thats when you assume ifrit will become immune to fire!
You seem to assume a lot, because thats not what i had said.
And sorry, but you really sound like one of those Bards...

Whether he is immune or he resists a portion of the damage is nearly irrelevant as you would still be penalized for not using the correct element. Do you even understand the implication of removing Fire from a Black Mage's rotation ? Or Blizzard for Shiva ?

And read his/her comments again, nothing he/she said is even remotely close to what you're implying. He/she even acknowledged otherwise.