3.0: Elemental Weakness/Resistance?

[Exstal]

Knight should have been the other tank job in this case.
Paladin is definitely a tank job.

Knight is Paladin as far as the Japanese are concerned.

All ranting aside, the Elemental Wheel is necessary because this is a Final Fantasy game, the Elemental Wheel has always been part of Final Fantasy from the very beginning, the Black Mage job has always, historically, been very closely tied in with the Elemental Wheel, and the entire game is themed around the very concept of the Elemental Wheel while mysteriously leaving it absent from the one aspect of the game where it really matters.

Your argument is pretty sound. I can't argue with that logic. Maybe if there is some kind of wild sweeping change of class / job system, ele wheel may come back but I also have a creeping suspicion that it's still not worth it.

[HakuroDK]

Knight is Paladin as far as the Japanese are concerned.

Really? I always thought they were different, and the FF Wikia has them listed as being two separate entries.

http://finalfantasy.wikia.com/wiki/Knight_%28Job%29
http://finalfantasy.wikia.com/wiki/Paladin_%28Job%29

I suppose they are interchangeable in a couple of games (like FFI), but there seems to be a distinction in FFIX, with Steiner being Knight and Beatrix being Paladin. But one thing's for sure. This is definitely a topic I should look into on my own time. Not here in this thread as it's unrelated, but still.

Your argument is pretty sound. I can't argue with that logic. Maybe if there is some kind of wild sweeping change of class / job system, ele wheel may come back but I also have a creeping suspicion that it's still not worth it.

Well as long as you can respect the validity of my argument, then I can respect your feelings as well.