I've followed along with the apple testing done in this thread and experienced the same results. Fed nothing but apples until I got to blood red (stopped feeding apples each time I got the new feather message). I then fed berries until I received the new feather message and now I have dalamud red. My end goal is wine red, but it doesn't seem like anyone has achieved this color with accurate testing.
I think if anyone is able to translate this page
http://jp.finalfantasyxiv.com/lodest...995.1375390680
more accurately than google translate we might be able to figure it out. It looks like the guy went from rolanberry red to wine red. Has anyone tried feeding pears to a rolanberry red choco?