Quote Originally Posted by Amberion View Post
They went from 12mil to 9mil subs during Cataclysm. Not sure what numbers you are looking at.

Just check the first pic you posted. It clearly shows stagnation during WoTLK and decline during cataclysm.
Decline would have been a better word than stagnation. So yes, it stagnated during a good part of Wrath and peaked at 12 Millions. I still have no ideas where you're getting your data about them losing their subs 2 months in.