I can't believe I actually have to explain this... Someone gearing up should always have priority over someone who wants something to glamour or desynth because they need to improve their character. (and if they have an alt, they should be running the dungeon for the gear they want with that alt). That should be completely obvious. That's like two people in the desert, but one person already has a bottle of water while the other one doesn't. They're both in the desert, yet the person who has the bottle of water finds more water, but takes it from the person who has none. And yes, I DID roll Need, as I stated in my original post.