Quote Originally Posted by Alcyon1 View Post
That's EXACTLY why I dislike WOW. Every single stupid mechanism as "good". No, a mechanism involving pure luck insn't "good", thi is a complete failure. The boss are too scripted, but the funny part is how Titan is THE fight you are always talking about. The game isn't about Titan, deal with it. Twintania is heavily scripted, but each fight is different and Twin doesn't have a rigid strategy. The last boss of Brayflox is also scripted, but this script is nicely done.

Randomness doesn't make fights better, this is just an illusion.
I like randomness. That's where skill actually comes in. A heavily scripted fight is relatively worse off. Twintania is a good example of a well scripted fight. You're stating that every Twintania fight is different, that in itself I take it to mean you find the fight more interesting than a fight where everything is exactly the same. Don't you think it could be even more interesting if some randomness was thrown in? The fights could be even more different and more challenging. It's of course important that it is properly balanced so you don't have to rely on RNGeezus to pass an encounter.