The conclusion of the Sylph and Amalj'aa tribe questlines. *SPOILERS*

[Alberel]

As for ur answers OP:
*Amaljaa:
1.She's not executed due to the relationship of the U tribe and the Immortal Flames, its very possible that the U tribe members whom we freed for BoA daily recognized she's still alive although may beyond cure. To kill her will have a disastrous effect to politics. And i believe she might be an "experiment guinea pig" to cure primal tempering.
2.At the BoA quest from recognized to friendly, imma sure u forgot the tempered IF guy who can bluff and lie about his loyalty to ifrit but acts normally like a normal peep. Not to add that the beastman tribes (Amaljaa, Slyph, Ixal, Kobold) were "tempered" differently from the 5 playable races. Theres a HUGE difference and effect from being tempered as a faithful servant who might sacrifice themselves to give powers to the primal extreme awakening and a slave

Good points. Other than the Amalj'aa themselves I'd not seen any others who spared tempered beings but you're right it's likely not everyone handles them the way the Immortal Flames do.

And yes you're right, I totally forgot about that tempered soldier who pretended to be with the Flames. That's what happens when you have to wait two weeks between quests I suppose... xD

I haven't actually done the Sylph quests so no comment there, but I completed the Amaljaa and my thoughts are:
Loonh Gah's mother says something about offering Loonh to Ifrit when you come up behind her, but she's definitely just a husk at this point. It's also the Immortal Flames/Scions that execute the tempered, The Brotherhood of Ash and the Miqo'te of Forgotten Springs may have different rules or beliefs about it. I might be wrong because I didn't really read over it properly but were the Brotherhood of Ash trying to cure the tempered (like in the "Losing One's Tempered" quest)?
And the leader of the Amaljaa was straight up lying, when Loonh turns around he immediately says "something something die" before he gets killed himself.

Loonh Gah's mother actually said something along the lines of 'You can't have my little Loonh Gah' in reference to the rock she was cradling. If anything that shows a direct opposition to Ifrit's will despite being tempered. I'm actually wondering if she may be the key to a cure based on the fact that the broken mind seems to have more freedom than a tempered one despite being part of the same effect.

Thanks for the replies guys!