Crafting Must change drastically, But the Current system most remain too.

[Peregrine]

I've tried two thousand needles.
Result 1: Thousand needle+2
Result 2: Thousand needle+3.

I assume you're crafting correctly as a real crafter, not a mats spammer trying to extrapolate it to gear that you aren't proficient at making. Odds of HQ'ing something at that quality is 30%, assuming you are actually doing what you're supposed to be.

If I'm incorrect in assuming you craft correctly, then I'll change my numbers to fit your nitpickery.
or rather, I'll just have you do it for me since nothing I said actually changes.

You probably just spammed needles at 24-30 quality and then hit enter, and the odds of +1 at that quality is about 1 in 30.

You know...the same as my silver and electrum ring HQ rate on the spam.

I find it all too expected that a crafter with so many levels so grossly focusses on spamming needles and the result thereof to define their existance.

I don't spam needles for 17 quality for a living, and that doesn't define blacksmithing.
You can either grind spam electrum rings and have a 1 in 30 chance of HQ, or you can take the time to maximize your touchups and quality ratios and increase that to about 1 in 8.

your choice. HQ or SP per hour. You choose SP per hour. That is why your HQ rates are so low.