Quote Originally Posted by Paikis View Post
400hp is basically a rounding error when you already have 8000hp. Your healers will overheal more than that amount on a regular basis. The only time that extra hp is worth having is if you survive with less than 400hp.
Bad logic, since Titan kills you with Mountain buster by only 500, then having 4.6k as a Paladin tank is acceptable.
More health is always better for tanking, simply because the strength does not increase the healing by IB significantly enought o beat out the 450 hp gained.
Parry is entirely luck based, and consistency is important.
Furthermore, having more HP means less overhealing, because you have a bigger gallon to fill.

Having 900 HP > getting 200 more HP from IB, and parrying 1% more often, which only works on physical abilities anyway.