Warrior "buff" in 2.1: not what we are expecting?

[Taemek]

Well, I hate to burst your bubble, but its kind of obvious that the other tank can't pull threat off you when you're packing 4 more DPS accessories, a helmet that is 35 ilvls higher, and gloves melded with DPS materia.

In other words, your anecdote doesn't prove that WARs deal 20-40% more damage than PLDs. Your anecdote proves that your WAR and your gear allows you to deal 20-40% more damage than the PLD and his gear.

I'm speechless, literally.

First the argument was that Shield Oath out DPS's Defiance stance - proved wrong, now, the PLD has to be in DPS gear while tanking in Shield Oath for a comparison.

Yeah..........truth is you guys are grasping at straws now days and the fact remains that Warriors out DPS PLD's by a considerable margin, end of story.