There would have to be a MAJOR oversight on our part (as players) for WAR to suddenly become on par with PLD. Given the amount of research we have already done, I find this unlikely.

1) if it's taken the entire playerbase this long to figure out, it's too well hidden. Therefore it is a design problem.

2) Perception is king. even if, on paper or in the data, they are roughly equal it won't matter. people feel WAR is weaker. therefore it is weaker.

3) The main comparison is performance in coil. Coil wasn't really designed to be done with the gear currently available pre-coil. so it's technically off-label use. If this is the case, than the issue isn't with WAR being weak, it is with PLD being too strong. it's able to do things it shouldn't be able to do. IE: consistenly tank mobs that are 10+ levels above your current iLvl.

-----------------------

There are a couple of things I don't like about WAR currently. I mentioned briefly a few things that could help. but the problem is far more deeply rooted than that.

both tanks have a 'mitigation' but it depends on your viewpoint. as far as an overall 'system' we can look at it like this:

HP is a resource. Damage removes the resource. Healing restores that resource.

A mob does damage. the tank takes damage. the healer restores damage.

Boiled down, Mitigation is the capability of the tank to restore 'free' HP to itself. This can be in the form of reducing the damage a mob does (PLD) or restored health (WAR). 'true' mitigation, however is really just reducing damage taken (PLD).

If we wanted to make paladin more on par with Warrior, Shield oath would need to be recast every 30 seconds. Spirits within, Cover, and Hallowed ground would need to remove shield oath, cost MP, and you could only apply shield oath after 2 Halone combos. to top it all off, Shield oath would need to constantly drain MP, similar to a bard song. (forcing you to work riot blade into your rotation) Sound stupid? you're right. it is.

but Why so severe?

looking back at the system for damage taken/restored. Paladin does its mitigation up front. War does its mitigation on the backend. Shield oath provides a persistent 20% mitigation as PLDs main form of mitigation. War, on the other hand does it on the back end. The difference with WAR is that it's a 15% to healing recieved, rather than a straight 20% from damage taken. However given that you must spend wrath stacks to use your secondary form of mitigation (IB, etc.), you lose the 15% temporarily.

so in the long run, WAR really only gets somewhere between 10-15% persistent mitigation. PLD always gets its 20%. Not only that, PLDs secondary forms of mitigation are at 0 cost. they don't take MP, they dont' take TP, they don't even consume the GCD.

Now you might argue that WAR has self healing to help bridge this gap. but keep in mind, we're still trying to bridge the gap between persistant mitigation. we haven't even touched the extra bonuses paladin gets between shield, parry, rampart, bulwark, and sentinel. WAR will need to spend the bulk of its active abilities simply trying bridge that persistent 20%. The mitigation gap is just too large. no amount of 'research' is going to bridge that gap.

-------------------------------------------

Now, there are a couple of abilities I rarely use on War. and so in the short term this will be where I focus my efforts.

1) Unchained

I never use this. I can't really see a point to it. you can't use it as an 'o shit' button like IB. you could potentially use it with berserk/blood bath/vengeance to get more health returned. but then you're losing the 15% healing received. I imagine this breaks even, or is close enough to not matter, in the long run. but I could be wrong. So i'll test it out in my own time. I have a feeling this is a lot like Sword Oath. it's an ability we aren't really meant to use that often.

2) Holmgang.

I can think of 0 situations where I would even attempt to use this. given how mobile you have to be to dodge attacks, why in the world would I ever bind myself? is this a potential hidden gem? if I bind myself can I avoid knockbacks like Repel? is that even really useful? when a mob does one if it's 'don't attack the tank' moves can I bind it and interrupt these abilities? I mean it doesn't even do damage... I suspect this is WARs answer to Cover. but I can't even bind something to run up and get hate back. Coupled with the high probability of this getting you killed...I'm pretty sure this isn't what we're missing either.

3) Stat allocation.

I wont' dive deep into this. it's fairly obvious. However all data I've seen has been inconclusive. that being said, I doubt us switching from VIT to STR builds or going with DD gear and attempting to tank with it will drastically improve our ability to stay alive. not to mention it's not intuitive to do this. if this is the intended stat allocation, its not clear enough. therefore it is bad design.