Tanaka or Yoshi?

[Mega]

The lesser of two evils hmm. The way I see it, it's not a Tanaka vs Yoshi issue as much as it is about Square Enix the company being an epic fail. The company has lost its way. Others may disagree and point to XIII's success and to that I guess I say SE doesnt understand me as a customer anymore.

[Ostia]

The lesser of two evils hmm. The way I see it, it's not a Tanaka vs Yoshi issue as much as it is about Square Enix the company being an epic fail. The company has lost its way. Others may disagree and point to XIII's success and to that I guess I say SE doesnt understand me as a customer anymore.

Those that point at XIII, just point at COD BO, way less of a game than MW & MW2 but hey its called call of duty, so is gonna sell like hotcakes.....

[Richard]

By the way, people still have roles in parties. I dont know what game you're playing, but try tanking an NM as an archer LOL. Good luck with that.

This is from Page 3, so I apologize for the delay but I've tanked Dodore on ARC as ARC/THM duo (pre-nerf). There really isn't much luck involved. lol

I have no opinion one way or the other about the OP though. Just thought I'd get a little fact troll in before bed!

[Kam]

This is from Page 3, so I apologize for the delay but I've tanked Dodore on ARC as ARC/THM duo. There really isn't much luck involved. lol

I have no opinion one way or the other about the OP though. Just thought I'd get a little fact troll in before bed!

Ive seen it done and thats what im working towards in this (current) mess of-a rushed game

[Speeral]

Ffxivcor or earozeapedia its in one of those first interviews
He still has a role in the progression

[Shai]

I know he has a role. It doesn't say what capacity that role is. I also have a role in the game's progression. I'm called "the consumer" or "the player." Tanaka is called "the consultant" which is pretty vague.

[Kiroh]

I know he has a role. It doesn't say what capacity that role is. I also have a role in the game's progression. I'm called "the consumer" or "the player." Tanaka is called "the consultant" which is pretty vague.

"Consultant" aka "We still want your input/advice on the game and it's direction but we don't want you getting any credit or publicity for it because the playerbase is still pissed off at you for the botched launch."

[Daedae]

Five years, and we get a shell of a game. Safe to say Tanaka's golden days are cataloged and shelved.

[Shai]

"Consultant" aka "We still want your input/advice on the game and it's direction but we don't want you getting any credit or publicity for it because the playerbase is still pissed off at you for the botched launch."

Right, but you're just making that up. The opposite of the statement in question.

[Nuru]

No.

Just no, stop it.

Tanaka is still working on the game. -_- Its not some Director Smackdown or anything, get an effin grip and do some research before you even begin to THINK about clicking the New Topic button.

I think Tanaka makes a better producer. The man with a bold vision.
I think Yoshida makes a better lead game designer. The MMO vet. He knows how to create that vision.

Without Tanaka, Yoshida runs the risk of developing a pat MMO that he likes from an uninspired consolidation of what he's played. Without Tanaka, Yoshida may create something that isn't its own. That's not Final Fantasy.

Without Yoshida, Tanaka just doesn't know how to work the MMO scene. God love him but if he's played ten hours of a MMO in his life I'll be a monkey's uncle.

I dunno what Komoto's role in any of this was, but Komoto should have been Yoshi-P.

The combination of Tanaka as Producer and Yoshida as director, I really like. With Yoshi-P doing almost all the talking because again. Not one of Tanaka's strong points.

Listen, ****ers! Shut up and listen!- Hiromichi "The Tank" Tanaka

This post was on page one, perfect. Stole the words right out of my mouth.