[Loremonger] 1.X Lominsan Story Arc

[Catapult]

Yeah, I still say this Echo is 1567~9 with a heavy skew towards the 7.

Is that not the most logical assumption?

The issue I have with this is the Starshower in Never the Twain Shall Meet. We've tied both the Gridanian and Ul'dahn story arcs to being ten years prior, concurrent with (or at least close to) the Battle of Silvertear Skies.

Why would the Limsan Shower just happen to occur five years later all of a sudden and still leave Y'shtola shocked that someone can use the Echo?

I'm not convinced. I think the 5-year comment is the red-herring or inconsistency.

((Typo correction: I'm not sure how much I'm willing to read into the 5-year statement.))

[Anonymoose]

Why would the Limsan Shower just happen to occur five years later all of a sudden and still leave Y'shtola shocked that someone can use the Echo?

Minfilia expresses exasperated confusion that for so long there were no Woken and now, in only the last few months, there are so many. Regardless of whether the echo takes place 5 or 10 years ago, it would have been during this dry spell, thus leaving Y'shtola stunned to find someone.

As to why it would be the only city that didn't have it happen in '62... that I don't know. However, Does the inclusion of a beast tribe as a threat in the story make the idea of it being in '62 extremely unlikely, however?