Back Paddling is horrible.

[Majidah]

Somewhere around the road this thread was turned into gamepad vs keyboard+mouse.

This thread is about back pedaling.
The setups for just keyboard, and just gamepad haven't been released yet, so there's only room for speculation.

What we can say for a fact, however, is the following:
-1.0 had a system that involved back pedaling without meddling with normal movement and no one ever complained.
-Turning around happens more often than having to back pedal.
-In moments of haste (running away from a special attack for example) you'll want to turn around, not back pedal.

Let me underline that.
What do you do more often? Turn around.
When there's no time to think, do you want to turn around or back pedal? Turn around.

Yet we are switching to a system that makes turning around more cumbersome than back pedaling. That makes no sense.

Don't try to reinvent the wheel. Or copy Blizzard's wheel.

[pool842]

Somewhere around the road this thread was turned into gamepad vs keyboard+mouse.

This thread is about back pedaling.
The setups for just keyboard, and just gamepad haven't been released yet, so there's only room for speculation.

What we can say for a fact, however, is the following:
-1.0 had a system that involved back pedaling without meddling with normal movement and no one ever complained.
-Turning around happens more often than having to back pedal.
-In moments of haste (running away from a special attack for example) you'll want to turn around, not back pedal.

Let me underline that.
What do you do more often? Turn around.
When there's no time to think, do you want to turn around or back pedal? Turn around.

Yet we are switching to a system that makes turning around more cumbersome than back pedaling. That makes no sense.

Don't try to reinvent the wheel. Or copy Blizzard's wheel.

So your saying the same thing yet you have no idea what your talking about great I guess I am done here. Yes you won't back peddle... YOU WILL USE YOUR CAMERA TO TURN....

[Neptune]

So your saying the same thing yet you have no idea what your talking about great I guess I am done here. Yes you won't back peddle... YOU WILL USE YOUR CAMERA TO TURN....

It's just not the same. It's not classy. Wait til you try to look around your character. You will feel like you're crudely trying to carve out camera angles, where before it was smooth as butter.

[Zelminar]

So your saying the same thing yet you have no idea what your talking about great I guess I am done here. Yes you won't back peddle... YOU WILL USE YOUR CAMERA TO TURN....

Maji is referring to the fact that you WILL have to resort to turning via the mouse or pressing the "A"/"D" keys. When in FFXIV v1 is was as simple as pressing "S" to make your 180 degree turn. Quick and easy.

Now I completely agree with Maji on this matter, however, it seems to be something we'll need to get used to and see what comes of it.

PS. Ummm Maji knows what he's talking about (bring it! POST #1! BRING IT!)

I'm more interested in seeing HOW they implement this scheme to gamepad.