the server would be so populated like the current servers.

i dont know how this would work. how many deaths you had in 1.0.? hundreds? that'd mean hundreds of new characters? I personally would get bored at the character creation screen then ;D

"lets fight garuda for the first time" "oh no sorry i heard she is too difficult we may die, especially on the first try". as the same for all other bosses. relic weapons or even primal weapons? forget about it. perma death doesnt work in -any- game.