I am still all for being "unlocked". I'm not saying something super difficult, just some kinda quest to unlock the level 1 book. That's all! Since the arch guild's been all closed doors and all, just have it as a simple quest to talk to people there or something, or collect super-simple to get item x5, or something. Or get some items from npc's around the city that equal same price as the weapons go for from npc normal. Simple things like that!

Also, note, that Yoshi-P has said you can only start as DoW/DoM until 10, so he's already limiting what new players can start as. Why would you want them to have the newest of the new jobs unlockable to them when no one will be able to answer any questions they may have? Not trying to be unfair, but let the vets have alittle time with them first, to get some experience with them, learn stats and cap and all that, ext. (Not that most jobs are hard or anything, but some people still durp rotations/sort up >_>)