FFXIV Live Question Submissions -- Comments. :)

[MerlinOmniking]

he meant in terms of gil making can a fisher make gil more than btn and miner alone without the help of DoH "No"
same as BSM he can make almost all of the class specific weapons minus 2 so he has an advantage

Fishing can make more gil than a botanist and miner( the catalysts that fishing gets is almost double what miner and botany get on my server{ossified matter -touch of rage- fished} ), sell catalysts and fish due to melding and the fact skirmish came out fish is in high demand to level alchemist to meld skirmish weapons. I can make as much gil if i pursued fishing; however, gil is determined by market not the class. I could make 0 gil on class weapons because everyone and there rmts undercut me and a billion gil on fisher because noone levels fisher for the catalysts/fish that u can only get by fishing. Each class has equal oppurtunity to make gil.

My only issue is that the market overflows the market with goods to sell. Does not matter which craft i make stuff on i make an equal amount of gil on each of my crafts in which i try to sell whats in demand and not overflooded. need to be able to play the market.

[Raubahn]

Fishing can make more gil than a botanist and miner( the catalysts that fishing gets is almost double what miner and botany get on my server{ossified matter -touch of rage- fished} ), sell catalysts and fish due to melding and the fact skirmish came out fish is in high demand to level alchemist to meld skirmish weapons. I can make as much gil if i pursued fishing; however, gil is determined by market not the class. I could make 0 gil on class weapons because everyone and there rmts undercut me and a billion gil on fisher because noone levels fisher for the catalysts/fish that u can only get by fishing. Each class has equal oppurtunity to make gil.

My only issue is that the market overflows the market with goods to sell. Does not matter which craft i make stuff on i make an equal amount of gil on each of my crafts in which i try to sell whats in demand and not overflooded. need to be able to play the market.

come to this corner please. Botanist can Harvest trilum bulbs which is used for "Class specific" weapon for cnj if its HQ it go up to 50k and more and not to mention Spruce logs also when they are HQ they go up for 100k

Miner oh boy oh boy. you can Dig up DS ore gold ore and Astral rocks which are all three of them are used in class specific weapons which if they were a +1 DS and Gold would go for 40-50k and Astral rock up to 100k

Fisher only high thing according to my server is Navigators ears which is sold for if they were hq 20k ~ so sum that all up rest is to fish is worthless because of botters.

again with the alchemy thing you are saying get this man if u had BSM,GSM,ALC you can make all the class specific weapons because u have miner and botanist and sell them for couple of 600k-1mil

my whole argument with you is this:

if player A has FSH.
B has Miner
C has BTN
and they all are 0 on all DoH
who will make most of the money?
B and C can make more gil because they have more resources for gil (3 for miner and 2 for btn) while A only resource is Catalyst according to you and in which B and C can gather it up also if they wanted too.