Results 1 to 10 of 150

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player

    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Posts
    401
    Quote Originally Posted by TimonLoon View Post
    PLD is currently complete and utter trash when compared to WAR for the following reason.

    - Cannot block WS but you can parry them. WAR wins.
    - Cannot mitigate incoming damage from enemy weapon skills, but WAR can with Feather Foot and Foresight.
    - Blocking does not reduce anywhere near as much damage as parrying. WAR wins.
    - WAR does more damage than PLD. More damage/more hate. WAR wins.
    - WAR has AoE damage. PLD does not (good bye Circle Slash). WAR wins.
    - Not many moves that reduce/virtually nullify attacks. Aegis Boon vs. Feather Foot/Foresight. WAR wins.
    - On a straight hit... An equally well equipped WAR takes less damage than a PLD. WAR wins.
    - PLD HP is still far lower than WAR. A PLD needs to gear hard on HP while a WAR can just focus on damage and Enmity. WAR wins.
    - PLD has AoE flash to get hate on multiple targets. Makes kiting Moogles easier. WAR needs to rely on having TP and Collusion -> Flare. PLD wins.
    - PLD can cure itself. WAR can also cure itself except it doesn't need MP (Rampage/Second Wind/Bloodbath). WAR wins.

    The only encounter in the game where PLD is better is Moogle Mog. And even that's arguable. PLD is in need of some serious buffs going into 2.0. The main problem with PLD is that it excels at virtually nothing. For almost every situation; WAR is better and deals more damage.

    DRG... Is currently 2nd on single target DPS behind PUG. I personally think they're fine. But if I had to nitpick... they have low durability due to their low HP and only cure being Second Wind. Life Surge doesn't count because there's very little to no reason to use it over Power Surge.
    well if no one else is gona do it......

    -before you even start compairing block and parry, compaired to block, parry is a completly random and rare event even with pary increasing stats and abilities. PLD wins with a 60-70% garenteed block rate.

    -fyi we can block weapon skills and if we do it with ageious boon, we get realy nice hp for it too ..... PLD wins

    -War dose do more damage then PLD but dose not pull more hate for all the damage they do, in fact enmity + gear works better for pld and we get enmity boosts for mind as well, along with the strongest enmity builders in the game. PLD wins

    - funny story about aoe hate controll, only off tanks and PL tanks need aoe hate controll, would make sense to give that to a lesser tank that can clean up trash mobs well, oh wait, BLMs do that too... Instead us poor PLDs get the honor of ACUTALLY tanking mobs like bosses and such having a much easier time with it too. PLD WINS

    -this next one just proves your an idiot and or troll. Stone skin, ageious boon, divine veil, rampart, sentinel and the only move in the game that negates magic and physical damage , hollowed ground. combine that with the normal deffensive boosts pld gets over war and once again ..... PLD WINS

    - next point your wrong for two reasons, 1 an equally equiped war will do shit for damage , 2 an equally equiped war will ALWAYS take more damage, sheild adds deffensive stats and traits, and PLD gets vit boost where war dose not.. PLD WINS

    - IN same exact gear, PLD has roughly 500 less hp then WAR, but mitigates roughly 10% more damage then war, lets do the math if avg hp for pld is 3400 a PLD would have to take less then 2 full hits to make up for the HP advantage war has... not many fights in wich I only get hit twice.... PLD WINS

    -you prove yourself wrong in this next point, WAR has stronger aoe hate controll, as posted per you, hense aoe hate controll gose to WAR especially on a fight where your kiteing , NOT tanking, this one gose to WAR, WAR WINS

    - TRUE STORY , PLD also gets blood bath and we more then make up for second wind with ageious boon lets not forget being able to regen mp and hp with blocks.... after all when taking less damage then a war you dont often need self heals, PLD WINS

    And lastly your last statment about pld sums up your entire knowledge of tanking on the game wich is nothing. PLD EXCELS AT TANKING , put up your sword and axe and help the game a bit.
    (2)

  2. #2
    Player
    Doho's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Location
    Ul'dah
    Posts
    699
    Character
    Doho Fiasco
    World
    Hyperion
    Main Class
    Armorer Lv 50
    Quote Originally Posted by Aceofspades View Post
    Grand list of PLD Pwnage
    thank you, sir. you've made us all proud! SPREAD THE PALADIN GOSPEL!
    (0)
    "Unbelievable wipes... indescribable failings. Whining, bitching, rage quitting - through an endless party find." - Doho, A Whole New Whorl