Page 40 of 41 FirstFirst ... 30 38 39 40 41 LastLast
Results 391 to 400 of 407
  1. #391
    Player
    Pixieh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    89
    Character
    Unhinged Gremlin
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    Where does it say that it should be the player's choice?
    Common sense. Taking an established player choice away after a decade is absolute shit. Excuse the french.
    (3)

  2. #392
    Player
    Mikey_R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,816
    Character
    Mike Aettir
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Valence View Post
    So you're essentially for the entire removal of job intricacies and in favor of the entire game based on encounter design, or what did I understand poorly here?
    Counter point, jobs have no intricacies without some sort of external factor to play around.

    To elaborate, take any job we have and go against a striking dummy. Can you name any job that really has intricacies you need to play around in order to do your rotation? I cannot think of any as any sort of choice is already pre-determined or based on RNG, where most of the time, you use the result of that RNG. As some examples, whether you use Spiral Blow or Lance Barrage after True Thrust/Raiden Thrust is a choice driven by which one leads to the most damage, whether you use Verstone or Verfire on Redmage isn't based on the fight, it is based on your rotation and whether it has proced or not, Refulgent Arrow? Use when it procs.

    Now, if we were to put some jobs into an encounter position, suddenly, we have to change how we do things in order to play around the encounter mechanics. Those insta casts on BLM? save for movement heavy phases, the blade combo on Paladin? Move it around the burst window to account for any time you are at range etc. The problem is, encounters do not push jobs to take advantage of these things that often.

    Taking a slight detour, let's talk about PvP. Take the PvP kit and attack a striking dummy. It isn't that exciting and you realise how shallow the PvP jobs are, even more so than the PvE jobs. However, put them in a PvP environment, and people say the PvP jobs are well designed. That is to say, the environment is what makes the PvP jobs what they are.

    Bringing this back to PvE, with more changes coming to the encounter design, for example, removing the mandated drop in mechanics every 2 mins to account for the burst window. If every job has different ways to tackle an encounter, does this not help to differentiate the jobs from each other? There could even be cases where different people approach the same fight on the same job in different ways with no loss to damage.

    Of course, job design is important, but let's not pretend that encounter design doesn't play a massive role as well.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    Common sense. Taking an established player choice away after a decade is absolute shit. Excuse the french.
    Players complained all tanks play the same, SE decides to give tanks different roles to help differentiate tanks from each other, players complain that they made tanks different.

    That isn't even an exaggeration as to what is going on here. If you were to have all tanks occupy both the MT and OT roles, you are just going back to square 1, where every tank has to have all the tools and thereby making them the same again. Not to mention, just because something has been done for a while, doesn't mean it is the right thing to do.
    (2)

  3. #393
    Player
    DjGameKing's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2018
    Location
    Limsa Lominsa
    Posts
    49
    Character
    Damon Tyranel
    World
    Omega
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    The entire point is that it should be a players choice whether to be that main tank or off tank.

    SE is taking that choice from us. Taking away player choice like that is never okay and is just absolutely horrendous design. Period. Full stop.
    Except they aren't. You are saying this like Square will actively make content unclearable if you ever try to main tank on Evolved WAR, Evolved DRK or Evolved GNB or try to off tank on Evolved PLD or Bastion. There is genuinely 0 reason to believe they are taking that choice away from us, since the off tanks still need to be able to go through dungeons, they still need to be able to tank alliance raids, they still need to be able to tank in case of a tank swap (whether by mechanic or untimely tank death) and they still need to be able to tank in case of dual boss/adds. So, your nightmare scenario is not gonna happen and you can just ask your party to MT on GNB. The worst you'll get is that they say no because GNB is named an OT, which is fair enough to be annoyed by. An alternative name might've been better, something like counter tank and support tank for MT and OT respectively, but at that point I think no label would've been better and just do the change without ever saying anything.

    Hell, they literally said that this is only for Evolved tanks, because surprise surprise, it is how the kit design will focus for these tanks rather than some draconian enforcement of "playing the way the correct way". Same with pure healing vs barrier healing. You notice how the tools the healers have gotten in their kits since the EW levels are more focused on one or the other? Because that is the extent to how much the split ended up mattering aka not much at all, aside from making double pure healing worse for mitigation and even that comp can still clear any fight in the game.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    Common sense. Taking an established player choice away after a decade is absolute shit. Excuse the french.
    That is thought terminating. Your opinion isn't the universal truth, especially since that "choice" has only been a choice in the sense of Square never figuring it out. Keep in mind that in HW PLD was meant to be MT and WAR OT with DRK acting as a hybrid. See how well that worked out with HW's meta. SB got slightly closer, but also only because WAR was very bad on SB release and after its rework in 4.2, we were back to HW, just with PLD being OT to WAR's MT and DRK being left in the dust.
    (3)

  4. #394
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    Players complained all tanks play the same, SE decides to give tanks different roles to help differentiate tanks from each other, players complain that they made tanks different.

    That isn't even an exaggeration as to what is going on here. If you were to have all tanks occupy both the MT and OT roles, you are just going back to square 1, where every tank has to have all the tools and thereby making them the same again. Not to mention, just because something has been done for a while, doesn't mean it is the right thing to do.
    This exactly. If tank classes do not have actual differences (which have a meaningful impact on the outcome of a fight) there is no reason to have more than a single tank class. Which is where the common complaint originates from that all 4 current tanks are effectively just vfx swaps, you can even run near-equivalent hotbar setups for them. To the point where I press my 120s CD on DRK every 60s right after pressing the 60s, because for the other 3 tanks it's 2x60s CDs and it's easier to have 1 set of muscle memory than 2 and it loses me nothing to press the button despite it still being on CD.

    Even in the new setup, there is still no reason for Paladin and Bastion respectively Gunbreaker, Dark Knight and Warrior, to exist as separate classes. They're less different than specs of the same role on a single class are in other MMORPGs, they absolutely do not need to be fully separate classes you level independently. But given historical reason that is something I can somewhat accept, even if it annoys me on a design-level.

    So for a hypothetical best-case evolved mode scenario, I'd imagine things like this, assuming 12 class-action buttons:

    - 7-8 shared buttons. While the actual actions and some secondary effects differ, these are ultimately the same across all 5 tanks. Basic filler rotation, basic damage CD, basic set of defensive and tanking tools.
    - ~2 subrole shared buttons. These differ between the MTs and the OTs, but are shared within each group.
    - 2-3 class-unique buttons. Things such as Paladin wings count, but the cover-intercept does not assuming all tanks have a gapcloser (then it's in the first option, implementation details just differ per class). This is where Warrior just has 3 buttons for various self-healing, Dark Knights get TBN as an extra CD, Gunbreakers look sad because of their poor design, that kind of stuff.

    But I just can't see that truly happen. If the 2-3 abilities in the final slot are meant to be meaningful, they would give 5 specializations, and the forum would just explode with rage, considering how well-received 2 specializations are. I suspect the last category will be entirely fluff, the middle one will be maybe slightly bigger and have more meaning, and the first one absorbs the rest.

    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    Common sense. Taking an established player choice away after a decade is absolute shit. Excuse the french.
    Oh I agree, but only insofar that it took a whole decade to do it. It should have at-worst happened with the first expansion afterwards, when it was obvious how necessary tank identities are. Instead bowing to continous player crying that swapping classes is haaaaaaaaaard, they kept sanding things off until we are now in the era where the forums are littered with "OMG all tanks the same!"-threads, yet the moment devs try to finally, finally, change that, people immediately decry that they find their boring not-class not-design comfy and don't want to see that changed.

    Plus you conveniently stopped reading at that sentence you quoted, lest you have to explain how this "common sense" of yours is uniquely only applicable to tanks, not to other roles.
    (2)
    Last edited by Carighan; 09-18-2026 at 06:30 PM.

  5. #395
    Player
    Valence's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2018
    Posts
    6,025
    Character
    Sunie Mochi
    World
    Twintania
    Main Class
    Machinist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    I'd prefer intricate class designs, definitely. In particular, I prefer class designs that want to actually designate a class. As in, giving you unique strengths, but also weaknesses.
    And current PCT/VPR supposedly do this better?

    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    Counter point, jobs have no intricacies without some sort of external factor to play around.
    Nobody said jobs play in a vacuum?
    (0)
    Secretly had a crush on Mao

  6. #396
    Player
    Absurdity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Posts
    3,633
    Character
    Tiana Vestoria
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    Players complained all tanks play the same, SE decides to give tanks different roles to help differentiate tanks from each other, players complain that they made tanks different.
    We can only speculate but this split is completely pointless unless they make the two sub-roles actually different, and that includes mitigation, which I honestly doubt they will do.

    Tanks played distinctly different when they didn't all have a 20% mit on 90s, a 40% mit on 120 seconds, a 20-30% mit on 25 seconds and some random flavour button and tank busters didn't just accomodate that exact cooldown setup.

    When Warrior just had to take some hits through having a giant health bar, when Paladin could just Cover you and take a buster with nothing but Shelltron but had to think about their 40% mit having a longer cooldown than anyone else, when Dark Knight had a leg up against magic damage because Dark Mind had the shortest cooldown of all defensives and some tanks simply struggled with mechanics that others didn't.

    Dark Mind is pretty much the only remainder of the old design, but as you said, fights never take advantage of Dark Knight's ability to eat high damage magic hits more frequently than any other tank.

    Unless they bring this old distinction back this split will be nothing but a fancy new coat of paint, because you're still approaching every fight the exact same way from a mitigation standpoint, regardless of whether you play an MT or OT job.
    (1)
    Last edited by Absurdity; 09-18-2026 at 09:40 PM.

  7. 09-18-2026 09:38 PM

  8. #397
    Player
    Absurdity's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Posts
    3,633
    Character
    Tiana Vestoria
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Warrior Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Carighan View Post
    Kiiiinda? They provide bad gameplay in less buttons, which is marginally less bad, even if it ain't better. So to speak.
    Which is entirely subjective. Yes the combos are a binary decisions with no intricacies, yes in outcome it makes no difference whether they're a single button or split into multiple, but in physical execution they could not be more different.
    I hate the auto-combo on Viper with a passion and if that becomes a non-optional feature for every single job in 8.0 I will already hate evolved before even touching it.
    I hate it just as much in pvp but the nature of the mode mitigates how much it annoys me.

    So no, the button consolidation is not "less bad".
    (0)
    Last edited by Absurdity; 09-18-2026 at 09:46 PM.

  9. #398
    Player
    Carighan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2018
    Posts
    2,693
    Character
    Carighan Maconar
    World
    Zodiark
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    I am confused about that, but it's also kinda off topic (like you could place the same button 3 times aside and keep pressing 3 different keys in sequence just like without an auto-combo), hence I deleted it again, then saw you had already replied. xD

    Anyhow, sorry, don't want to go too far offtopic for a tank forum thread.
    (0)

  10. #399
    Player
    Pixieh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    89
    Character
    Unhinged Gremlin
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    Right because the vast majority of tanks woke up one day and wanted to be budget tanks forever. Once more, it does not matter what MT and OT's can and cannot do, the vast majority of the playerbase will only go by labels. The vast majority of mankind only goes by labels. They won't educate themselves, they won't care. They will only see the game now labels 3 out of 5 tanks off tanks and that will be all that matters to the vast majority.

    OT's will be looked down upon. That's a fact.
    (2)

  11. #400
    Player
    Terhix's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    198
    Character
    Thane Ryder
    World
    Odin
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Pixieh View Post
    Right because the vast majority of tanks woke up one day and wanted to be budget tanks forever. Once more, it does not matter what MT and OT's can and cannot do, the vast majority of the playerbase will only go by labels. The vast majority of mankind only goes by labels. They won't educate themselves, they won't care. They will only see the game now labels 3 out of 5 tanks off tanks and that will be all that matters to the vast majority.

    OT's will be looked down upon. That's a fact.
    You keep asserting that people only look at labels, but this is just historically wrong. Again, with Aion, people looked down upon the offtank because it was just a bad class for the content. If you went into a dungeon as a tank you were griefing your healer, if you went in as dps you were griefing everybody since your dps was lower than a pure dps class. It had nothing to do with the label and everything to do with gameplay.

    The inverse was also true in XIV during HW: PLD was the official MT job, while WAR and DRK were meant to be offtanks. Except, PLD was just bad, so the meta ended up being WAR+DRK despite the labels. There is a non-zero probability that SE will screw the subrole split again, and we will have double offtank meta again.
    (2)

Page 40 of 41 FirstFirst ... 30 38 39 40 41 LastLast