Page 38 of 41 FirstFirst ... 28 36 37 38 39 40 ... LastLast
Results 371 to 380 of 407
  1. #371
    Player
    Lyth's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Location
    Meracydia
    Posts
    3,918
    Character
    Lythia Norvaine
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Beastmaster Lv 50
    There's nothing wrong with shaking things up. The designer for Evolved mode, Hikaru Tamaki, was also responsible for the changes to the PvP job action rework in 6.1, and you can see that influence in what we've seen so far from Evolved mode. Ideas like the DRG jump mitigation idea are creative and give jobs unique flavor, and I'm very interested to see what he does with this opportunity.

    What makes me worry is when the devs come in with a fixed expectation on how players will engage with those changes. One of the strengths of their pre-Stormblood game design is that they let emergent gameplay outcomes be for the most part and just observed what players did with them. It doesn't really matter if players tank a fight in a completely different way from how the fight was originally designed, or if they equip gear that's not intended for them (STR gear), or if they prioritize completely different stats from the ones you thought they would prioritize (Parry), so long as it doesn't trivialize content. Fighting this generally is not a good idea. Instead, it's better to ask why they're prioritizing things differently from your expectations, and to build on that organically.

    You won't convince people to care about Parry, so you're better off finding out what they care about instead. Tanks are (unexpectedly?) choosing to play in ways that push their damage? Lean into that. When game design becomes too tyrannical, players become frustrated and lose interest. The starting point shouldn't be 'let's split tanks into MT jobs and OT jobs'. That's the sort of decision that I'd expect from someone who hasn't observed how tanks do content for the past 10+ years. The starting point should be 'let's create interesting but different gameplay mechanics for each tank subrole that encourage players to approach tanking in a new way'.

    The counterattack mechanic is a really interesting concept with problems. They tried it out in Heavensward and Stormblood but eventually removed it. One of the drawbacks of the design was that PLD would use Sheltron on raidwides to generate Shield Swipe if they were not actively tanking, which made Intervention a dps loss. They've since experimented with it in the form of lost actions from exploratory content, as well as with BLU. I'm not sure what lessons they've extracted from observing players put it into action. What would have made me more confident in this decision is if they had instead said 'we've tried out counterattacks previously and run into the following problems, and this is how we intend on overcoming it.' Even if it doesn't work out, that shows me that they're taking into account player behavior. But the fact that we have the same implementation, with no comment on prior iterations of it, and no comment on a potential direction for the OT subrole makes me concerned that the starting point was 'let's enforce a split that tanks don't actually do in practice'.
    (2)

  2. #372
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    Without knowing how they done the interview, did they take notes or record the interview before making the article, it can mean things could get lost or misinterpreted, even if everything was done in the same language. It happens in English all the time and I see no reason why wouldn't happen in Japanese either.
    I don't know about you, but that interview sounds very set in stone to me.
    Need mt and ot in savage and higher.
    The invuln losing thing i meant exactly like i wrote
    In reborn all tanks have invulns and in evolved only the mts, because i think a ton of players will be playing tanks in reborn mode just because it doesn't limit you.
    Overall i think that reborn mode might be the preferred mode in the end once everyone understood that all jobs become summoner levels of difficulty
    All gauges fill on their own, no need to auto attack or use gcds, it just fills.
    That change is good for downtime and solves the "pictomancer is so strong in downtime because it can paint" problem.
    I think evolved mode won't have the slightest amount of skill expression.
    And what worries me the most is that the dev team very likely defines "identity" completely differently.
    My fear is that the "identity" giving unique things end up being more annoying or more of a hinderance than actually fun.
    Look at ninja. I dont think ninja for example keeps the mudra system. That takes up way too much space already.
    Instead we will get a 1 button mudra like in pvp wothout doing the combinations.
    It will be 5% job design, 95% mechanics. Highly speculative, sure, but from what i have seen so far it looks like that.
    (0)

  3. #373
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Lyth View Post
    The counterattack mechanic is a really interesting concept with problems. They tried it out in Heavensward and Stormblood but eventually removed it. One of the drawbacks of the design was that PLD would use Sheltron on raidwides to generate Shield Swipe if they were not actively tanking, which made Intervention a dps loss. They've since experimented with it in the form of lost actions from exploratory content, as well as with BLU. I'm not sure what lessons they've extracted from observing players put it into action. What would have made me more confident in this decision is if they had instead said 'we've tried out counterattacks previously and run into the following problems, and this is how we intend on overcoming it.' Even if it doesn't work out, that shows me that they're taking into account player behavior. But the fact that we have the same implementation, with no comment on prior iterations of it, and no comment on a potential direction for the OT subrole makes me concerned that the starting point was 'let's enforce a split that tanks don't actually do in practice'.
    Do you think that new tanking system will survive until 9.0? Because i don't. It has never worked in the history of this game.
    Arguably best gameplay we had was in shadowbringers imo. Stormblood still had too many mistakes in gameplay.
    Like whm for example and the whole lily system. Was very poorly designed.
    Shdowbringers rounded out some jobs very nicely. It was the starting point of homogenization, but without overdoing it.
    I think we should get back to there.
    (2)

  4. #374
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Looking at evolved mode in general it looks like job specific optimization could change a lot or be removed entirely.
    Evolved PLD loses its atonement manipulation. Granted, that gets replaced by the counter system, but counters will very likely be a main tank feature, so BST will have that aswell. So PLD got essentially reduced to lvl 70 PLD and they added the blade combo on top.

    Other optimzitations we currently have that could get removed or change a lot.
    BLM transpose lines and optimal aoe (Flare, Flare, Flarestar, Transpose, Freeze, High Thunder, Transpose, then repeat) rarely see anyone do these things ever.
    PCT Magenta skipping. Rarely seen because it's super tedious but clear damage gain
    MNK double Lunar opener or Lunar Solar opener depending on the fight's timeline, also the optimal drift tech
    SAM Kaeshi "smuggling" as some call it and the actually quite complicated Higanbana alignment manipulation
    DRG Mirage Dive smuggling, small optimization but it's there
    BRD Song alignment, likely gone because you probably just spam the songs to get the follow up combo unlocked

    And that's just to name a few. A lot of these things will get lost already because of the removal of the 2 minutes buffs, because alignment will not matter as much anymore
    (2)

  5. #375
    Player
    Lyth's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2015
    Location
    Meracydia
    Posts
    3,918
    Character
    Lythia Norvaine
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Beastmaster Lv 50
    I think they're committed to it for 8.x, given how averse they are to making large unplanned changes mid-expansion. What's more likely is that players will just ignore it and the balance will swing around based off of how much damage counters do. The two most worrying signs of this are the fact that PLD has lost none of its prior moveset under the transition, and the fact that Answering Strike can be procced off of any type of damage (which means that people will be using Sheltron on raidwides again). I wouldn't be surprised if double offtank or double main tank ironically ends up being enforced by the community, depending on how this balance pans out.

    The gameplay simplifications are at least on the playerbase, rather than the dev team. People bought into the influencer spiel on the 'two minute meta' despite it being repeatedly pointed out that removing raid buffs would be the natural consequence of this. Also, a lot of balance decisions to date seem to be made in reaction to player claims around 'complexity', which were really just a byproduct of how long a given job had been out since its last rework/release. I've always been of the mindset that if you enjoy the technical skill involved in a given job, then you should make a point of not drawing unnecessary attention to it - that's why BLM enjoyers had a pretty good run of historically. With so many self-proclaimed 'complex' jobs out there now demanding to be buffed over everyone else, I'm not at all surprised that this is the direction that we're trending in.
    (1)

  6. #376
    Player
    Kishin12345's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2025
    Posts
    190
    Character
    Eldin Valesk
    World
    Lich
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 60
    Quote Originally Posted by Lyth View Post
    I think they're committed to it for 8.x, given how averse they are to making large unplanned changes mid-expansion. What's more likely is that players will just ignore it and the balance will swing around based off of how much damage counters do. The two most worrying signs of this are the fact that PLD has lost none of its prior moveset under the transition, and the fact that Answering Strike can be procced off of any type of damage (which means that people will be using Sheltron on raidwides again). I wouldn't be surprised if double offtank or double main tank ironically ends up being enforced by the community, depending on how this balance pans out.

    The gameplay simplifications are at least on the playerbase, rather than the dev team. People bought into the influencer spiel on the 'two minute meta' despite it being repeatedly pointed out that removing raid buffs would be the natural consequence of this. Also, a lot of balance decisions to date seem to be made in reaction to player claims around 'complexity', which were really just a byproduct of how long a given job had been out since its last rework/release. I've always been of the mindset that if you enjoy the technical skill involved in a given job, then you should make a point of not drawing unnecessary attention to it - that's why BLM enjoyers had a pretty good run of historically. With so many self-proclaimed 'complex' jobs out there now demanding to be buffed over everyone else, I'm not at all surprised that this is the direction that we're trending in.
    Very good post. I see it exactly that way aswell!
    The changes to blm in this expansion were due to low playrate.
    Historically this happened quite often if a job had low playrates due to various reason like being too bloated or too "hard" or just too different to play.
    That's why MNK or AST got changed changed pretty much every expansion
    (2)

  7. #377
    Player
    Mikey_R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,816
    Character
    Mike Aettir
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Kishin12345 View Post
    I don't know about you, but that interview sounds very set in stone to me.[1]
    Need mt and ot in savage and higher.[2]
    The invuln losing thing i meant exactly like i wrote[3]
    In reborn all tanks have invulns and in evolved only the mts, because i think a ton of players will be playing tanks in reborn mode just because it doesn't limit you.[4]
    Overall i think that reborn mode might be the preferred mode in the end once everyone understood that all jobs become summoner levels of difficulty[5]
    All gauges fill on their own, no need to auto attack or use gcds, it just fills.[6]
    That change is good for downtime and solves the "pictomancer is so strong in downtime because it can paint" problem.[7]
    I think evolved mode won't have the slightest amount of skill expression. [8]
    And what worries me the most is that the dev team very likely defines "identity" completely differently.[9]
    My fear is that the "identity" giving unique things end up being more annoying or more of a hinderance than actually fun.[10]
    Look at ninja. I dont think ninja for example keeps the mudra system. That takes up way too much space already.[11]
    Instead we will get a 1 button mudra like in pvp wothout doing the combinations.[12]
    It will be 5% job design, 95% mechanics. Highly speculative, sure, but from what i have seen so far it looks like that.[13]
    [1]Not to me, different interpretations.
    [2]No you don't, Reborn mode still exists which do not fill the MT/OT roles.
    [3]Considering how strong invulns are, that would be a point against OTs as the Reborn tanks would still have them and they would still be a viable pick.
    [4]But you cannot design things around what you suspect people will pick, you have to design it around all possibilities.
    [5]Depends how they handle everything and how the fights evolve around them.
    [6]From what we have seen, we do not know if other jobs might be different. It is also worth pointing out that the gauges are literally just stackable oGCDs. We will need to see how other jobs built before we make a final decision on how good the system is going to be.
    [7]Depends how much potency you get from it. If Picto got barely any potency gain from painting in downtime, it wouldn't have been an issue.
    [8]Whilst I know where the sentiment comes from, I am waiting until we see encounters before making a final verdict on it. Hoe good an encounter is is based off of job kits and fight design after all.
    [9]I've said this for a long time, what do people actually mean when they say 'identity'. Saying Dragoon should have jumps is a different idea to a Monk that should do steady, non burst DPS.
    [10]Hard to say without knowing more. But we do have Reborn mode to fall back on and I suspect the dev will keep track of how many players are using one over the other and adjust from there.
    [11]Which is a valid concern. I can say the same about Monk and having 6 GCDs just for their single target combo, that is basically have of the available space, assuming Perfect Balance stays as it is. This is also a job I play often and am concerned about how they are going to approach it, but there isn't anything I can do except see what they have planned.
    [12]You could have a system where you press 'Ninjutsu', it changes 3 buttons to Ten, Chi, Jin, then you press the 'Ninjutsu' button again to fire off the Ninjutsu. That is 4 buttons for the basic mudra system whilst keeping buttons that can be used for other things. Just as a suggestion.
    [13]Definitely highly speculative as we haven't seen any fights yet.

    However, to bring things back to tanking. Reborn mode is something that throws a massive spanner in the idea that you HAVE to have an OT. It has been stated many times, both in interviews and on stage that Reborn mode does NOT follow the MT/OT system, which means that, whatever they cook up for OT, it has to be job related and cannot rely on an encounter for it to function. This is the main thing to point out with MT, yes, they have a counter, but they can counter in any content, this isn't a savage and above mechanic, which does make me think that there is something else going on that we do not know about. To go back slightly, since Reborn doesn't follow the MT/OT styles, this means, in theory, you can take a Bastion MT and Reborn Paladin and clear the fight fine. Which does go back to what they have planned, which I suspect, we do not know. We don't even know anything about Rampart or Guardian, neither was used in the dev panel so we have no idea if the cooldown has changed, the duration has changed or even if they mitigation amount has changed.

    This is why I keep saying from the MT/OT and tanks in general, stop dooming and glooming about something we know basically bugger all about (especially if it is dooming and glooming about nothing other than the names MT/OT). Instead, either wait patiently and express concerns about what we do know, or speculate about what they could have planned to make OT exciting, as they say.
    (1)

  8. #378
    Player
    DjGameKing's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2018
    Location
    Limsa Lominsa
    Posts
    49
    Character
    Damon Tyranel
    World
    Omega
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post
    We don't even know anything about Rampart or Guardian, neither was used in the dev panel so we have no idea if the cooldown has changed, the duration has changed or even if they mitigation amount has changed.
    We do actually see Guardian used. From the development panel video (if it doesn't start at the right time, 54:18): https://youtu.be/_uiNEwa7oT4?t=3258. The things we can ascertain from it is that Yoshi-P clicked on Mr. Prime's character, used Guardian and that Guardian mostly looks the same (120s cooldown, 2 buffs, one being a shield as we see it applied in the party list). What we can speculate is on if the off tank 40% cooldowns can be placed on people, since it is otherwise a weird move from Yoshi-P to target his co-tank right before pressing Guardian, and whether the mitigation % has changed at all, but those get 1) slightly into tinfoil hat and 2) really just kind of comes down to "sure is possible."
    (1)

  9. #379
    Player
    Mikey_R's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,816
    Character
    Mike Aettir
    World
    Cerberus
    Main Class
    Paladin Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by DjGameKing View Post
    We do actually see Guardian used. From the development panel video (if it doesn't start at the right time, 54:18): https://youtu.be/_uiNEwa7oT4?t=3258. The things we can ascertain from it is that Yoshi-P clicked on Mr. Prime's character, used Guardian and that Guardian mostly looks the same (120s cooldown, 2 buffs, one being a shield as we see it applied in the party list). What we can speculate is on if the off tank 40% cooldowns can be placed on people, since it is otherwise a weird move from Yoshi-P to target his co-tank right before pressing Guardian, and whether the mitigation % has changed at all, but those get 1) slightly into tinfoil hat and 2) really just kind of comes down to "sure is possible."
    Guess I missed mentioning it in the topic I made (or I didn't bother), either way, we still don't know if they are still 40% mitigations or not, and whether they share the same structure between the tanks or if it is different between MT/OT.

    Having them be shared with another party member would be interesting, but we can also do that with the short cooldowns, if they all survive that is. Having a 40% mitigation is also going to be very powerful when applied to a party member, In my opinion, I don't see it being the case, but TBN is also a very strong shield currently.

    We are definitely still in a too many questions, not enough answers stage. The media tour cannot come soon enough.
    (0)

  10. #380
    Player
    Pixieh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    89
    Character
    Unhinged Gremlin
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by Mikey_R View Post

    And you don't think the playerbase will adapt around the potentially weird naming convention when they realise what it actually entails?
    I have zero faith in that happening. The vast majority will refer to the labels only because why bother learning more when the tanks are clearly marked as main and budget tanks? It was different in the early days of mmorpg's but it's been like this for the past 20 years and it won't change. People love labeling things and sticking to it, this is def a highschool situation and it's going to suck.

    Edit: I have seen this happening before. Started back in Aion where you had the main tank Templar and the off tank Gladiator. People only wanted 'real' tanks aka the Templar. It repeated right after when Tera was released with Lancer and Warrior and its been the same since. The vast majority see no reason to educate themselves about a class/classes they don't play, the game tells them they just got put into a duty with an off tank and they'll look down upon that thank for not being a main tank.

    This is not me dooming, this is me speaking from experiencing it in different games over and over again and being realistic about the vast majority of the playerbase in ANY mmorpg.
    (1)
    Last edited by Pixieh; 09-16-2026 at 01:44 PM.

Page 38 of 41 FirstFirst ... 28 36 37 38 39 40 ... LastLast